Execution Chart

We display below the execution chart for this examination (boot time has been removed).

Trace from the execution

Formatting '/data/fkordon/mcc2023-input.r330-tall-167889203300474.qcow2', fmt=qcow2 size=4294967296 backing_file=/data/fkordon/mcc2023-input.qcow2 cluster_size=65536 lazy_refcounts=off refcount_bits=16
Waiting for the VM to be ready (probing ssh)
..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
=====================================================================
Generated by BenchKit 2-5348
Executing tool marciexred
Input is Referendum-PT-0015, examination is CTLFireability
Time confinement is 3600 seconds
Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes
Number of cores is 4
Run identifier is r330-tall-167889203300474
=====================================================================

--------------------
preparation of the directory to be used:
/home/mcc/execution
total 864K
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 19K Feb 26 17:27 CTLCardinality.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 132K Feb 26 17:27 CTLCardinality.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 12K Feb 26 17:25 CTLFireability.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 93K Feb 26 17:25 CTLFireability.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 4.2K Jan 29 11:41 GenericPropertiesDefinition.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 6.8K Jan 29 11:41 GenericPropertiesVerdict.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 12K Feb 25 16:42 LTLCardinality.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 49K Feb 25 16:42 LTLCardinality.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 4.4K Feb 25 16:42 LTLFireability.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 29K Feb 25 16:42 LTLFireability.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 27K Feb 26 17:29 ReachabilityCardinality.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 172K Feb 26 17:29 ReachabilityCardinality.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 25K Feb 26 17:28 ReachabilityFireability.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 209K Feb 26 17:28 ReachabilityFireability.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 2.5K Feb 25 16:42 UpperBounds.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 5.7K Feb 25 16:42 UpperBounds.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 5 Mar 5 18:23 equiv_col
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 5 Mar 5 18:23 instance
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 6 Mar 5 18:23 iscolored
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 18K Mar 5 18:23 model.pnml

--------------------
content from stdout:

=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)

The expected result is a vector of booleans
BOOL_VECTOR

here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-00
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-01
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-02
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-03
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-04
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-05
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-06
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-07
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-08
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-09
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-10
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-11
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-12
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-13
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-14
FORMULA_NAME Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-15

=== Now, execution of the tool begins

BK_START 1679164271112

bash -c /home/mcc/BenchKit/BenchKit_head.sh 2> STDERR ; echo ; echo -n "BK_STOP " ; date -u +%s%3N
Invoking MCC driver with
BK_TOOL=marciexred
BK_EXAMINATION=CTLFireability
BK_BIN_PATH=/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/
BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT=3600
BK_INPUT=Referendum-PT-0015
Applying reductions before tool marcie
Invoking reducer
Running Version 202303021504
[2023-03-18 18:31:12] [INFO ] Running its-tools with arguments : [-pnfolder, /home/mcc/execution, -examination, CTLFireability, -timeout, 360, -rebuildPNML]
[2023-03-18 18:31:12] [INFO ] Parsing pnml file : /home/mcc/execution/model.pnml
[2023-03-18 18:31:12] [INFO ] Load time of PNML (sax parser for PT used): 25 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:12] [INFO ] Transformed 46 places.
[2023-03-18 18:31:12] [INFO ] Transformed 31 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:12] [INFO ] Found NUPN structural information;
[2023-03-18 18:31:12] [INFO ] Parsed PT model containing 46 places and 31 transitions and 76 arcs in 82 ms.
Parsed 16 properties from file /home/mcc/execution/CTLFireability.xml in 14 ms.
Support contains 16 out of 46 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 46/46 places, 31/31 transitions.
Reduce places removed 30 places and 0 transitions.
Ensure Unique test removed 15 transitions
Reduce isomorphic transitions removed 15 transitions.
Iterating post reduction 0 with 45 rules applied. Total rules applied 45 place count 16 transition count 16
Applied a total of 45 rules in 9 ms. Remains 16 /46 variables (removed 30) and now considering 16/31 (removed 15) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 16 rows 16 cols
[2023-03-18 18:31:12] [INFO ] Computed 0 place invariants in 4 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 386 ms returned []
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Invariant cache hit.
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 47 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 458 ms to find 0 implicit places.
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Invariant cache hit.
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 36 ms found 0 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 1 : 16/46 places, 16/31 transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 504 ms. Remains : 16/46 places, 16/31 transitions.
Support contains 16 out of 16 places after structural reductions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Initial state reduction rules for CTL removed 1 formulas.
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 17 ms
FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-09 FALSE TECHNIQUES TOPOLOGICAL INITIAL_STATE
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 7 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 16 transitions.
Incomplete random walk after 10000 steps, including 588 resets, run finished after 356 ms. (steps per millisecond=28 ) properties (out of 43) seen :39
Incomplete Best-First random walk after 10001 steps, including 73 resets, run finished after 39 ms. (steps per millisecond=256 ) properties (out of 4) seen :0
Incomplete Best-First random walk after 10001 steps, including 73 resets, run finished after 33 ms. (steps per millisecond=303 ) properties (out of 4) seen :0
Incomplete Best-First random walk after 10001 steps, including 73 resets, run finished after 38 ms. (steps per millisecond=263 ) properties (out of 4) seen :0
Incomplete Best-First random walk after 10001 steps, including 73 resets, run finished after 33 ms. (steps per millisecond=303 ) properties (out of 4) seen :0
Running SMT prover for 4 properties.
[2023-03-18 18:31:13] [INFO ] Invariant cache hit.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] After 49ms SMT Verify possible using all constraints in real domain returned unsat :3 sat :0 real:1
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] After 38ms SMT Verify possible using all constraints in natural domain returned unsat :4 sat :0
Fused 4 Parikh solutions to 0 different solutions.
Parikh walk visited 0 properties in 1 ms.
Successfully simplified 4 atomic propositions for a total of 15 simplifications.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 5 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Initial state reduction rules for CTL removed 2 formulas.
FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-04 FALSE TECHNIQUES TOPOLOGICAL INITIAL_STATE
FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-02 FALSE TECHNIQUES TOPOLOGICAL INITIAL_STATE
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 5 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 16 transitions.
Computed a total of 16 stabilizing places and 16 stable transitions
Complete graph has no SCC; deadlocks are unavoidable. place count 16 transition count 16
Detected that all paths lead to deadlock. Applying this knowledge to assert that all AP eventually converge (and all enablings converge to false).
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 1 ms. Remains 16 /16 variables (removed 0) and now considering 16/16 (removed 0) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 1 ms. Remains : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 2 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 2 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 16 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 0 ms. Remains 16 /16 variables (removed 0) and now considering 16/16 (removed 0) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 1 ms. Remains : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 2 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 7 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 16 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 0 ms. Remains 16 /16 variables (removed 0) and now considering 16/16 (removed 0) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 0 ms. Remains : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 2 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 16 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 1 ms. Remains 16 /16 variables (removed 0) and now considering 16/16 (removed 0) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 1 ms. Remains : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 16 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in SI_CTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 2 ms. Remains 16 /16 variables (removed 0) and now considering 16/16 (removed 0) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in SI_CTL mode , in 1 iterations and 2 ms. Remains : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 2 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 16 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in SI_CTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 1 ms. Remains 16 /16 variables (removed 0) and now considering 16/16 (removed 0) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in SI_CTL mode , in 1 iterations and 1 ms. Remains : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 2 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 16 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in SI_CTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Graph (complete) has 15 edges and 16 vertex of which 2 are kept as prefixes of interest. Removing 14 places using SCC suffix rule.1 ms
Discarding 14 places :
Also discarding 14 output transitions
Drop transitions removed 14 transitions
Applied a total of 1 rules in 2 ms. Remains 2 /16 variables (removed 14) and now considering 2/16 (removed 14) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in SI_CTL mode , in 1 iterations and 2 ms. Remains : 2/16 places, 2/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 0 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 2 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Discarding 8 places :
Symmetric choice reduction at 0 with 8 rule applications. Total rules 8 place count 8 transition count 8
Iterating global reduction 0 with 8 rules applied. Total rules applied 16 place count 8 transition count 8
Applied a total of 16 rules in 2 ms. Remains 8 /16 variables (removed 8) and now considering 8/16 (removed 8) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 2 ms. Remains : 8/16 places, 8/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 8 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Discarding 6 places :
Symmetric choice reduction at 0 with 6 rule applications. Total rules 6 place count 10 transition count 10
Iterating global reduction 0 with 6 rules applied. Total rules applied 12 place count 10 transition count 10
Applied a total of 12 rules in 1 ms. Remains 10 /16 variables (removed 6) and now considering 10/16 (removed 6) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 1 ms. Remains : 10/16 places, 10/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 0 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 0 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 10 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in SI_CTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Graph (complete) has 15 edges and 16 vertex of which 2 are kept as prefixes of interest. Removing 14 places using SCC suffix rule.1 ms
Discarding 14 places :
Also discarding 14 output transitions
Drop transitions removed 14 transitions
Applied a total of 1 rules in 1 ms. Remains 2 /16 variables (removed 14) and now considering 2/16 (removed 14) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in SI_CTL mode , in 1 iterations and 1 ms. Remains : 2/16 places, 2/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 0 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 2 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Discarding 9 places :
Symmetric choice reduction at 0 with 9 rule applications. Total rules 9 place count 7 transition count 7
Iterating global reduction 0 with 9 rules applied. Total rules applied 18 place count 7 transition count 7
Applied a total of 18 rules in 1 ms. Remains 7 /16 variables (removed 9) and now considering 7/16 (removed 9) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 1 ms. Remains : 7/16 places, 7/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 7 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Discarding 4 places :
Symmetric choice reduction at 0 with 4 rule applications. Total rules 4 place count 12 transition count 12
Iterating global reduction 0 with 4 rules applied. Total rules applied 8 place count 12 transition count 12
Applied a total of 8 rules in 1 ms. Remains 12 /16 variables (removed 4) and now considering 12/16 (removed 4) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 1 ms. Remains : 12/16 places, 12/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 12 transitions.
Starting structural reductions in LTL mode, iteration 0 : 16/16 places, 16/16 transitions.
Discarding 2 places :
Symmetric choice reduction at 0 with 2 rule applications. Total rules 2 place count 14 transition count 14
Iterating global reduction 0 with 2 rules applied. Total rules applied 4 place count 14 transition count 14
Applied a total of 4 rules in 1 ms. Remains 14 /16 variables (removed 2) and now considering 14/16 (removed 2) transitions.
Finished structural reductions in LTL mode , in 1 iterations and 1 ms. Remains : 14/16 places, 14/16 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 1 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 14 transitions.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 4 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 4 ms
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Export to MCC of 13 properties in file /home/mcc/execution/CTLFireability.sr.xml took 4 ms.
[2023-03-18 18:31:14] [INFO ] Export to PNML in file /home/mcc/execution/model.sr.pnml of net with 16 places, 16 transitions and 31 arcs took 1 ms.
Total runtime 1764 ms.
There are residual formulas that ITS could not solve within timeout
timeout --kill-after=10s --signal=SIGINT 1m for testing only

Marcie built on Linux at 2019-11-18.
A model checker for Generalized Stochastic Petri nets

authors: Alex Tovchigrechko (IDD package and CTL model checking)

Martin Schwarick (Symbolic numerical analysis and CSL model checking)

Christian Rohr (Simulative and approximative numerical model checking)

marcie@informatik.tu-cottbus.de

called as: /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//../reducer/bin//../../marcie/bin/marcie --net-file=model.pnml --mcc-file=CTLFireability.xml --memory=6 --mcc-mode

parse successfull
net created successfully

Net: Petri
(NrP: 16 NrTr: 16 NrArc: 31)

parse formulas
formulas created successfully
place and transition orderings generation:0m 0.000sec

net check time: 0m 0.000sec

init dd package: 0m 2.731sec


RS generation: 0m 0.000sec


-> reachability set: #nodes 31 (3.1e+01) #states 32,769 (4)



starting MCC model checker
--------------------------

checking: EG [AF [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5]]]
normalized: EG [~ [EG [~ [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2
.................
EG iterations: 17
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-08 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.002sec

checking: EG [AG [EF [EG [[p12<=0 & 0<=p12]]]]]
normalized: EG [~ [E [true U ~ [E [true U EG [[p12<=0 & 0<=p12]]]]]]]

abstracting: (0<=p12)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2

EG iterations: 0
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-12 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.000sec

checking: AG [[AF [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] & [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | E [~ [[AG [[p8<=1 & 1<=p8]] | EX [[p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]] U [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]]
normalized: ~ [E [true U ~ [[~ [EG [~ [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] & [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]]]] | E [~ [[EX [[p15<=1 & 1<=p15]] | ~ [E [true U ~ [[p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]]]] U [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-13 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.000sec

checking: EG [[EX [[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [[p14<=0 & 0<=p14] & EG [[p14<=0 & 0<=p14]]]]] & [[p9<=0 & 0<=p9] | ~ [A [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] U [[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]] & AG [[p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]]]]]]
normalized: EG [[[~ [[~ [EG [~ [[~ [E [true U ~ [[p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] & [[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [[~ [E [true U ~ [[p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] & [[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]] U [~ [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11]] & ~ [[~ [E [true U ~ [[p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] & [[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]]]] | [p9<=0 & 0<=p9]] & EX [[[EG [[p14<=0 & 0<=p14]] & [p14<=0 & 0<=p14]] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p14)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p14)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2
.abstracting: (0<=p9)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)

EG iterations: 0
.................
EG iterations: 17
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-10 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.002sec

checking: EF [[E [[A [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] U [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]] U [EX [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11]] | AG [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13]]]] & [AX [AG [[p6<=0 & 0<=p6]]] & [AG [AX [[[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] & [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]]] | [[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | EF [[[p0<=0 & 0<=p0] & [p13<=0 & 0<=p13]]]]]]]]
normalized: E [true U [E [[[~ [EG [~ [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14]]]] & ~ [E [~ [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] U [~ [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11]] & ~ [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14]]]]]] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]] U [~ [E [true U ~ [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13]]]] | EX [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]]] & [[~ [E [true U EX [~ [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] & [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]]]]]] | [E [true U [[p13<=0 & 0<=p13] & [p0<=0 & 0<=p0]]] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] & ~ [EX [E [true U ~ [[p6<=0 & 0<=p6]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (0<=p6)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p0)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p0<=0)
states: 32,768 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p13)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-11 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.002sec

checking: EX [[EF [[[[[p1<=0 & 0<=p1] & [p4<=0 & 0<=p4]] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] & AX [[p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] & [~ [E [[[[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] & [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] U [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]]] | [EX [[[p2<=0 & 0<=p2] | [p3<=0 & 0<=p3]]] & [[p3<=0 & 0<=p3] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]]]]]]
normalized: EX [[E [true U [~ [EX [~ [[p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] & [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [[p4<=0 & 0<=p4] & [p1<=0 & 0<=p1]]]]] & [[[[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p3<=0 & 0<=p3]] & EX [[[p3<=0 & 0<=p3] | [p2<=0 & 0<=p2]]]] | ~ [E [[[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] & [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]]] U [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p2)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p3)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
.abstracting: (0<=p3)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p4)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-14 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.001sec

checking: ~ [E [[[[E [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] U [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]] | [[[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] & [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]] | [EX [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] & E [[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] U [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]]]] & E [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] U [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | ~ [EX [[[[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]] & AG [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]]]]] U AG [[E [[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] U [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] & [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]] | ~ [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5]]]]]]]
normalized: ~ [E [[~ [EX [[[[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]] & ~ [E [true U ~ [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]]]]]] | [E [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] U [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]] & [[[E [[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] U [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]] & EX [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6]]] | [[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] & [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]]] | E [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] U [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]]]] U ~ [E [true U ~ [[[~ [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] & [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | E [[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] U [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-15 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.001sec

checking: AF [[AX [[[[~ [[1<=p1 & p1<=1]] & [~ [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] & ~ [[p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]]] & [[~ [[p4<=1 & 1<=p4]] & ~ [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5]]] & [~ [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] & ~ [[p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]]] & [[[~ [[p8<=1 & 1<=p8]] & ~ [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9]]] & [~ [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] & ~ [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]]] & [[~ [[p12<=1 & 1<=p12]] & ~ [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13]]] & [~ [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] & ~ [[p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]] & [AF [AG [[[[[p1<=0 & 0<=p1] & [[p2<=0 & 0<=p2] & [p3<=0 & 0<=p3]]] & [[[p4<=0 & 0<=p4] & [p5<=0 & 0<=p5]] & [[p6<=0 & 0<=p6] & [p7<=0 & 0<=p7]]]] & [[[[p8<=0 & 0<=p8] & [p9<=0 & 0<=p9]] & [[p10<=0 & 0<=p10] & [p11<=0 & 0<=p11]]] & [[[p12<=0 & 0<=p12] & [p13<=0 & 0<=p13]] & [[p14<=0 & 0<=p14] & [p15<=0 & 0<=p15]]]]]]] & [p0<=0 & 0<=p0]]]]
normalized: ~ [EG [~ [[~ [EX [~ [[[[[~ [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] & ~ [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] & [~ [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] & ~ [[p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] & [[~ [[p15<=1 & 1<=p15]] & ~ [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14]]] & [~ [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] & ~ [[p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]]]] & [[[~ [[p7<=1 & 1<=p7]] & ~ [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6]]] & [~ [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] & ~ [[p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]]] & [[~ [[p3<=1 & 1<=p3]] & ~ [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2]]] & ~ [[1<=p1 & p1<=1]]]]]]]] & [[p0<=0 & 0<=p0] & ~ [EG [E [true U ~ [[[[[[p15<=0 & 0<=p15] & [p14<=0 & 0<=p14]] & [[p13<=0 & 0<=p13] & [p12<=0 & 0<=p12]]] & [[[p11<=0 & 0<=p11] & [p10<=0 & 0<=p10]] & [[p9<=0 & 0<=p9] & [p8<=0 & 0<=p8]]]] & [[[[p7<=0 & 0<=p7] & [p6<=0 & 0<=p6]] & [[p5<=0 & 0<=p5] & [p4<=0 & 0<=p4]]] & [[[p3<=0 & 0<=p3] & [p2<=0 & 0<=p2]] & [p1<=0 & 0<=p1]]]]]]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (0<=p1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p2)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p3)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p4)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p5)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p6)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p7)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p8)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p9)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p10)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p11)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p12)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p13)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p14)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p15)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
.................
EG iterations: 17
abstracting: (0<=p0)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p0<=0)
states: 32,768 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.................
EG iterations: 16
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-00 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.001sec

checking: A [EG [~ [A [[[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]] & EX [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]] U AX [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]]]] U [[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]
normalized: [~ [EG [~ [[[[[[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]] | [[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]] | [[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [[[[[[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]] | [[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]] | [[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]]]] U [~ [[[[[[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]] | [[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]] | [[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]]]] & ~ [EG [~ [[~ [EG [EX [~ [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]]]] & ~ [E [EX [~ [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]] U [~ [[[[[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]]] | [[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]] & EX [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]] & EX [~ [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]]]]]]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..................
EG iterations: 17
.................
EG iterations: 17
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-01 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.002sec

checking: A [[EG [[AF [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]] | EX [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]]] & [p0<=1 & 1<=p0]] U EG [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]]
normalized: [~ [EG [~ [EG [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [EG [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]] U [~ [[[p0<=1 & 1<=p0] & EG [[EX [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]] | ~ [EG [~ [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]]]]]] & ~ [EG [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
................
EG iterations: 16
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..................
EG iterations: 17
abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
................
EG iterations: 16
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
................
EG iterations: 16

EG iterations: 0
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-05 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.002sec

checking: [EF [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]] & AG [[AF [[[[[p1<=0 & 0<=p1] & [[p2<=0 & 0<=p2] & [p3<=0 & 0<=p3]]] & [[[p4<=0 & 0<=p4] & [p5<=0 & 0<=p5]] & [[p6<=0 & 0<=p6] & [p7<=0 & 0<=p7]]]] & [[[[p8<=0 & 0<=p8] & [p9<=0 & 0<=p9]] & [[p10<=0 & 0<=p10] & [p11<=0 & 0<=p11]]] & [[[p12<=0 & 0<=p12] & [p13<=0 & 0<=p13]] & [[p14<=0 & 0<=p14] & [p15<=0 & 0<=p15]]]]]] | E [[~ [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]] & AF [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]] U ~ [AG [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]]]]]]
normalized: [~ [E [true U ~ [[E [[~ [EG [~ [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]] & ~ [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]] U E [true U ~ [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]] | ~ [EG [~ [[[[[[p15<=0 & 0<=p15] & [p14<=0 & 0<=p14]] & [[p13<=0 & 0<=p13] & [p12<=0 & 0<=p12]]] & [[[p11<=0 & 0<=p11] & [p10<=0 & 0<=p10]] & [[p9<=0 & 0<=p9] & [p8<=0 & 0<=p8]]]] & [[[[p7<=0 & 0<=p7] & [p6<=0 & 0<=p6]] & [[p5<=0 & 0<=p5] & [p4<=0 & 0<=p4]]] & [[[p3<=0 & 0<=p3] & [p2<=0 & 0<=p2]] & [p1<=0 & 0<=p1]]]]]]]]]]] & E [true U [[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p2)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p3)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p4)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p5)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p6)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p7)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p8)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p9)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p10)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p11)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p12)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p13)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p14)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p15)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
................
EG iterations: 16
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-06 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.001sec

checking: AF [EG [[~ [A [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0] U [[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]] & [[[[[[p1<=0 & 0<=p1] & [[p2<=0 & 0<=p2] & [p3<=0 & 0<=p3]]] & [[[p4<=0 & 0<=p4] & [p5<=0 & 0<=p5]] & [[p6<=0 & 0<=p6] & [p7<=0 & 0<=p7]]]] & [[[[p8<=0 & 0<=p8] & [p9<=0 & 0<=p9]] & [[p10<=0 & 0<=p10] & [p11<=0 & 0<=p11]]] & [[[p12<=0 & 0<=p12] & [p13<=0 & 0<=p13]] & [[p14<=0 & 0<=p14] & [p15<=0 & 0<=p15]]]]] | [EG [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]] & EG [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]]] & [[[[EG [[[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]] | [[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]]]]
normalized: ~ [EG [~ [EG [[[[[[[EG [[[[[[[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]] | [[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]]] | [[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]] | [[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]] | [[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]]] | [[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]]] | [[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]]] & [[EG [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]] & EG [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]] | [[[[[p15<=0 & 0<=p15] & [p14<=0 & 0<=p14]] & [[p13<=0 & 0<=p13] & [p12<=0 & 0<=p12]]] & [[[p11<=0 & 0<=p11] & [p10<=0 & 0<=p10]] & [[p9<=0 & 0<=p9] & [p8<=0 & 0<=p8]]]] & [[[[p7<=0 & 0<=p7] & [p6<=0 & 0<=p6]] & [[p5<=0 & 0<=p5] & [p4<=0 & 0<=p4]]] & [[[p3<=0 & 0<=p3] & [p2<=0 & 0<=p2]] & [p1<=0 & 0<=p1]]]]]] & ~ [[~ [EG [~ [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]] U [~ [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]] & ~ [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2
abstracting: (0<=p1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p2)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p3)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p4)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p5)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p6)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p7)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p8)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p9)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p10)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p11)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p12)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p13)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p14)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p15)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
................
EG iterations: 16
abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
..
EG iterations: 2
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
................
EG iterations: 16
.
EG iterations: 1

EG iterations: 0
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-07 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.001sec

checking: EF [[[A [[[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]] & ~ [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]] U EX [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]] & AX [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]] & [EF [[p0<=0 & 0<=p0]] & [E [[[[[[p0<=1 & 1<=p0] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]] U [[[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]] | [[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]] & [[[[[p1<=0 & 0<=p1] & [[p2<=0 & 0<=p2] & [p3<=0 & 0<=p3]]] & [[[p4<=0 & 0<=p4] & [p5<=0 & 0<=p5]] & [[p6<=0 & 0<=p6] & [p7<=0 & 0<=p7]]]] & [[[[p8<=0 & 0<=p8] & [p9<=0 & 0<=p9]] & [[p10<=0 & 0<=p10] & [p11<=0 & 0<=p11]]] & [[[p12<=0 & 0<=p12] & [p13<=0 & 0<=p13]] & [[p14<=0 & 0<=p14] & [p15<=0 & 0<=p15]]]]] | [[[[[p1<=0 & 0<=p1] & [p2<=0 & 0<=p2]] & [[p3<=0 & 0<=p3] & [p4<=0 & 0<=p4]]] & [[[p5<=0 & 0<=p5] & [p6<=0 & 0<=p6]] & [[p7<=0 & 0<=p7] & [p8<=0 & 0<=p8]]]] & [[[[p9<=0 & 0<=p9] & [p10<=0 & 0<=p10]] & [[p11<=0 & 0<=p11] & [p12<=0 & 0<=p12]]] & [[[p13<=0 & 0<=p13] & [p14<=0 & 0<=p14]] & [[p15<=0 & 0<=p15] & [[[[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [[p2<=1 & 1<=p2] | [p3<=1 & 1<=p3]]] | [[[p4<=1 & 1<=p4] | [p5<=1 & 1<=p5]] | [[p6<=1 & 1<=p6] | [p7<=1 & 1<=p7]]]] | [[[[p8<=1 & 1<=p8] | [p9<=1 & 1<=p9]] | [[p10<=1 & 1<=p10] | [p11<=1 & 1<=p11]]] | [[[p12<=1 & 1<=p12] | [p13<=1 & 1<=p13]] | [[p14<=1 & 1<=p14] | [p15<=1 & 1<=p15]]]]]]]]]]]]]]
normalized: E [true U [[[E [[[[[[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]] | [[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [[p1<=1 & 1<=p1] | [p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]]] | [[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]]] U [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]] | [[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]] & [[[[[[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]] & [p15<=0 & 0<=p15]] & [[p14<=0 & 0<=p14] & [p13<=0 & 0<=p13]]] & [[[p12<=0 & 0<=p12] & [p11<=0 & 0<=p11]] & [[p10<=0 & 0<=p10] & [p9<=0 & 0<=p9]]]] & [[[[p8<=0 & 0<=p8] & [p7<=0 & 0<=p7]] & [[p6<=0 & 0<=p6] & [p5<=0 & 0<=p5]]] & [[[p4<=0 & 0<=p4] & [p3<=0 & 0<=p3]] & [[p2<=0 & 0<=p2] & [p1<=0 & 0<=p1]]]]] | [[[[[p15<=0 & 0<=p15] & [p14<=0 & 0<=p14]] & [[p13<=0 & 0<=p13] & [p12<=0 & 0<=p12]]] & [[[p11<=0 & 0<=p11] & [p10<=0 & 0<=p10]] & [[p9<=0 & 0<=p9] & [p8<=0 & 0<=p8]]]] & [[[[p7<=0 & 0<=p7] & [p6<=0 & 0<=p6]] & [[p5<=0 & 0<=p5] & [p4<=0 & 0<=p4]]] & [[[p3<=0 & 0<=p3] & [p2<=0 & 0<=p2]] & [p1<=0 & 0<=p1]]]]]] & E [true U [p0<=0 & 0<=p0]]] & [~ [EX [~ [[[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]]] & [~ [EG [~ [EX [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [EX [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]] U [~ [[~ [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]] & [[[[[p15<=1 & 1<=p15] | [p14<=1 & 1<=p14]] | [[p13<=1 & 1<=p13] | [p12<=1 & 1<=p12]]] | [[[p11<=1 & 1<=p11] | [p10<=1 & 1<=p10]] | [[p9<=1 & 1<=p9] | [p8<=1 & 1<=p8]]]] | [[[[p7<=1 & 1<=p7] | [p6<=1 & 1<=p6]] | [[p5<=1 & 1<=p5] | [p4<=1 & 1<=p4]]] | [[[p3<=1 & 1<=p3] | [p2<=1 & 1<=p2]] | [p1<=1 & 1<=p1]]]]]] & ~ [EX [[p0<=1 & 1<=p0]]]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.
EG iterations: 0
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
.abstracting: (0<=p0)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p0<=0)
states: 32,768 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p2)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p3)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p4)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p5)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p6)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p7)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p8)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p9)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p10)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p11)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p12)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p13)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p14)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p15)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p2)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p3)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p4)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p5)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p6)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p7)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p8)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p9)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p10)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p11)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p12)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p13)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p14)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (0<=p15)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=0)
states: 16,385 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p8)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p8<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p9)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p9<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p10)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p10<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p11)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p11<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p12)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p12<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p13)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p13<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p14)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p14<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p15)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p15<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p0)
states: 1
abstracting: (p0<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p1)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p1<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p2)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p2<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p3)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p3<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p6)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p6<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p7)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p7<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p4)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p4<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
abstracting: (1<=p5)
states: 16,384 (4)
abstracting: (p5<=1)
states: 32,769 (4)
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA Referendum-PT-0015-CTLFireability-03 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.001sec

totally nodes used: 12516 (1.3e+04)
number of garbage collections: 0
fire ops cache: hits/miss/sum: 9461 10916 20377
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 20807 67088057 16 1024MB
basic ops cache: hits/miss/sum: 8108 9900 18008
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 19019 16758197 12 192MB
unary ops cache: hits/miss/sum: 0 0 0
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 0 16777216 8 128MB
abstract ops cache: hits/miss/sum: 0 0 0
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 0 16777216 12 192MB
state nr cache: hits/miss/sum: 1236 393 1629
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 393 8388215 32 256MB
max state cache: hits/miss/sum: 0 0 0
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 0 8388608 32 256MB
uniqueHash elements/entry size/size: 67108864 4 256MB
0 67096729
1 11776
2 337
3 22
4 0
5 0
6 0
7 0
8 0
9 0
>= 10 0

Total processing time: 0m 4.367sec


BK_STOP 1679164279771

--------------------
content from stderr:

+ ulimit -s 65536
+ [[ -z '' ]]
+ export LTSMIN_MEM_SIZE=8589934592
+ LTSMIN_MEM_SIZE=8589934592
+ export PYTHONPATH=/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/pylibs
+ PYTHONPATH=/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/pylibs
+ export LD_LIBRARY_PATH=/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/pylibs:
+ LD_LIBRARY_PATH=/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/pylibs:
++ sed s/.jar//
++ ls /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//../reducer/bin//../../itstools//itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.application.pnmcc_1.0.0.202303021504.jar
++ perl -pe 's/.*\.//g'
+ VERSION=202303021504
+ echo 'Running Version 202303021504'
+ /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//../reducer/bin//../../itstools//itstools/its-tools -pnfolder /home/mcc/execution -examination CTLFireability -timeout 360 -rebuildPNML
check for maximal unmarked siphon
ok
check for constant places
ok
check if there are places and transitions
ok
check if there are transitions without pre-places
ok
check if at least one transition is enabled in m0
ok
check if there are transitions that can never fire
ok


initing FirstDep: 0m 0.000sec


iterations count:47 (2), effective:16 (1)

initing FirstDep: 0m 0.000sec


iterations count:32 (2), effective:2 (0)

iterations count:17 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:33 (2), effective:3 (0)

iterations count:17 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:17 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:17 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:17 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:31 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:32 (2), effective:2 (0)

iterations count:31 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:17 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:17 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:32 (2), effective:2 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:32 (2), effective:15 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:33 (2), effective:3 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:31 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:32 (2), effective:2 (0)

iterations count:31 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:30 (1), effective:14 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:31 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:32 (2), effective:15 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:16 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:32 (2), effective:15 (0)

iterations count:31 (1), effective:1 (0)

iterations count:31 (1), effective:1 (0)

Sequence of Actions to be Executed by the VM

This is useful if one wants to reexecute the tool in the VM from the submitted image disk.

set -x
# this is for BenchKit: configuration of major elements for the test
export BK_INPUT="Referendum-PT-0015"
export BK_EXAMINATION="CTLFireability"
export BK_TOOL="marciexred"
export BK_RESULT_DIR="/tmp/BK_RESULTS/OUTPUTS"
export BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT="3600"
export BK_MEMORY_CONFINEMENT="16384"
export BK_BIN_PATH="/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/"

# this is specific to your benchmark or test

export BIN_DIR="$HOME/BenchKit/bin"

# remove the execution directoty if it exists (to avoid increse of .vmdk images)
if [ -d execution ] ; then
rm -rf execution
fi

# this is for BenchKit: explicit launching of the test
echo "====================================================================="
echo " Generated by BenchKit 2-5348"
echo " Executing tool marciexred"
echo " Input is Referendum-PT-0015, examination is CTLFireability"
echo " Time confinement is $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT seconds"
echo " Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes"
echo " Number of cores is 4"
echo " Run identifier is r330-tall-167889203300474"
echo "====================================================================="
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "preparation of the directory to be used:"

tar xzf /home/mcc/BenchKit/INPUTS/Referendum-PT-0015.tgz
mv Referendum-PT-0015 execution
cd execution
if [ "CTLFireability" = "ReachabilityDeadlock" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "UpperBounds" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "QuasiLiveness" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "StableMarking" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "Liveness" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "OneSafe" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "StateSpace" ]; then
rm -f GenericPropertiesVerdict.xml
fi
pwd
ls -lh

echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stdout:"
echo
echo "=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)"
echo
if [ "CTLFireability" = "UpperBounds" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of positive values"
echo NUM_VECTOR
elif [ "CTLFireability" != "StateSpace" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of booleans"
echo BOOL_VECTOR
else
echo "no data necessary for post analysis"
fi
echo
if [ -f "CTLFireability.txt" ] ; then
echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)"
for x in $(grep Property CTLFireability.txt | cut -d ' ' -f 2 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
elif [ -f "CTLFireability.xml" ] ; then # for cunf (txt files deleted;-)
echo echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from xml file)"
for x in $(grep '' CTLFireability.xml | cut -d '>' -f 2 | cut -d '<' -f 1 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
elif [ "CTLFireability" = "ReachabilityDeadlock" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "QuasiLiveness" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "StableMarking" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "Liveness" ] || [ "CTLFireability" = "OneSafe" ] ; then
echo "FORMULA_NAME CTLFireability"
fi
echo
echo "=== Now, execution of the tool begins"
echo
echo -n "BK_START "
date -u +%s%3N
echo
timeout -s 9 $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT bash -c "/home/mcc/BenchKit/BenchKit_head.sh 2> STDERR ; echo ; echo -n \"BK_STOP \" ; date -u +%s%3N"
if [ $? -eq 137 ] ; then
echo
echo "BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT_REACHED"
fi
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stderr:"
echo
cat STDERR ;