Execution Chart

We display below the execution chart for this examination (boot time has been removed).

Trace from the execution

Formatting '/data/fkordon/mcc2023-input.r289-tall-167873940200273.qcow2', fmt=qcow2 size=4294967296 backing_file=/data/fkordon/mcc2023-input.qcow2 cluster_size=65536 lazy_refcounts=off refcount_bits=16
Waiting for the VM to be ready (probing ssh)
...............
=====================================================================
Generated by BenchKit 2-5348
Executing tool marcie
Input is PhilosophersDyn-COL-03, examination is CTLCardinality
Time confinement is 3600 seconds
Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes
Number of cores is 1
Run identifier is r289-tall-167873940200273
=====================================================================

--------------------
preparation of the directory to be used:
/home/mcc/execution
total 484K
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 7.5K Feb 26 12:07 CTLCardinality.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 75K Feb 26 12:07 CTLCardinality.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 7.6K Feb 26 12:06 CTLFireability.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 69K Feb 26 12:06 CTLFireability.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 4.2K Jan 29 11:40 GenericPropertiesDefinition.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 6.3K Jan 29 11:40 GenericPropertiesVerdict.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 3.8K Feb 25 16:33 LTLCardinality.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 25K Feb 25 16:33 LTLCardinality.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 2.4K Feb 25 16:33 LTLFireability.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 18K Feb 25 16:33 LTLFireability.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 13K Feb 26 12:08 ReachabilityCardinality.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 119K Feb 26 12:08 ReachabilityCardinality.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 7.0K Feb 26 12:08 ReachabilityFireability.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 50K Feb 26 12:08 ReachabilityFireability.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 1.8K Feb 25 16:33 UpperBounds.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 3.8K Feb 25 16:33 UpperBounds.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 5 Mar 5 18:23 equiv_pt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 3 Mar 5 18:23 instance
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 5 Mar 5 18:23 iscolored
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 31K Mar 5 18:23 model.pnml

--------------------
content from stdout:

=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)

The expected result is a vector of booleans
BOOL_VECTOR

here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-00
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-01
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-02
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-03
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-04
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-05
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-06
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-07
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-08
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-09
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-10
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-11
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-12
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-13
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-14
FORMULA_NAME PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-15

=== Now, execution of the tool begins

BK_START 1678763908576

bash -c /home/mcc/BenchKit/BenchKit_head.sh 2> STDERR ; echo ; echo -n "BK_STOP " ; date -u +%s%3N
Invoking MCC driver with
BK_TOOL=marcie
BK_EXAMINATION=CTLCardinality
BK_BIN_PATH=/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/
BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT=3600
BK_INPUT=PhilosophersDyn-COL-03
Not applying reductions.
Model is COL
CTLCardinality COL
timeout --kill-after=10s --signal=SIGINT 1m for testing only

Marcie built on Linux at 2019-11-18.
A model checker for Generalized Stochastic Petri nets

authors: Alex Tovchigrechko (IDD package and CTL model checking)

Martin Schwarick (Symbolic numerical analysis and CSL model checking)

Christian Rohr (Simulative and approximative numerical model checking)

marcie@informatik.tu-cottbus.de

called as: /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//../marcie/bin/marcie --net-file=model.pnml --mcc-file=CTLCardinality.xml --memory=6 --mcc-mode

parse successfull
net created successfully

Unfolding complete |P|=30|T|=84|A|=591
Time for unfolding: 0m 0.555sec

Net: PhilosophersDyn_COL_03
(NrP: 30 NrTr: 84 NrArc: 564)

parse formulas
formulas created successfully
place and transition orderings generation:0m 0.000sec

net check time: 0m 0.000sec

init dd package: 0m 2.906sec


RS generation: 0m 0.008sec


-> reachability set: #nodes 448 (4.5e+02) #states 325



starting MCC model checker
--------------------------

checking: ~ [EG [EG [~ [sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=25]]]]
normalized: ~ [EG [EG [~ [sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=25]]]]

abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=25)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
.
EG iterations: 1
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-07 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.027sec

checking: EF [~ [21<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]]
normalized: E [true U ~ [21<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]]

abstracting: (21<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 0
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-08 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.025sec

checking: AF [AX [[EG [EG [11<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]] & 1<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]
normalized: ~ [EG [EX [~ [[EG [EG [11<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]] & 1<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]]]

abstracting: (1<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 213
abstracting: (11<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.
EG iterations: 1
.
EG iterations: 1
.....
EG iterations: 4
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-11 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.054sec

checking: EG [~ [46<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]
normalized: EG [~ [46<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]

abstracting: (46<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 0

EG iterations: 0
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-02 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.023sec

checking: AF [AX [A [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) U EG [[sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=22 & sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]]]]
normalized: ~ [EG [EX [~ [[~ [EG [~ [EG [[sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=22 & sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [EG [[sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=22 & sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]] U [~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)] & ~ [EG [[sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=22 & sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 276
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=22)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 276
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=22)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 276
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=22)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
..
EG iterations: 2
.....
EG iterations: 4
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-00 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.056sec

checking: ~ [EF [E [~ [AG [EX [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=49]]] U A [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)] U ~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=70]]]]]
normalized: ~ [E [true U E [E [true U ~ [EX [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=49]]] U [~ [EG [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=70]] & ~ [E [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=70 U [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) & sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=70]]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=70)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 235
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=70)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=70)
states: 325

EG iterations: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=49)
states: 325
.-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-14 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.082sec

checking: [EF [~ [[AG [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)] | AG [A [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1) U 20<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]]] & AF [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)]]
normalized: [~ [EG [~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)]]] & E [true U ~ [[~ [E [true U ~ [[~ [EG [~ [20<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]] & ~ [E [~ [20<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] U [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)] & ~ [20<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]] | ~ [E [true U ~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 325
abstracting: (20<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 130
abstracting: (20<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (20<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 0

EG iterations: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 243
.
EG iterations: 1
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-04 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.076sec

checking: E [AF [~ [EX [[[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1) | sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=80] | E [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1) U 27<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]]] U [~ [AX [~ [A [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=47 U sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)]]]] | [~ [[AG [~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=21]] & 86<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]] & 9<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]]]
normalized: E [~ [EG [EX [[E [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1) U 27<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)] | [sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1) | sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=80]]]]] U [[~ [[~ [E [true U sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=21]] & 86<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]] & 9<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)] | EX [[~ [EG [~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)]]] & ~ [E [~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)] U [~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=47] & ~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=47)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
.abstracting: (9<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (86<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=21)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=80)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 169
abstracting: (27<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 313
.....
EG iterations: 4
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-06 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.194sec

checking: E [EX [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=84]] U A [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=100 U [[[~ [[sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=75 | 32<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]] | [80<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) & sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=100]] & [A [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) U sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55] & 96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]] | sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=59]]]
normalized: E [EX [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=84]] U [~ [EG [~ [[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=59 | [[[~ [E [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55] U [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)] & ~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55]]]] & ~ [EG [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55]]]] & 96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)] & [[80<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) & sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=100] | ~ [[sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=75 | 32<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=59 | [[[~ [E [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55] U [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)] & ~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55]]]] & ~ [EG [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55]]]] & 96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)] & [[80<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) & sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=100] | ~ [[sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=75 | 32<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]]]]]] U [~ [[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=59 | [[[~ [E [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55] U [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)] & ~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55]]]] & ~ [EG [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55]]]] & 96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)] & [[80<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) & sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=100] | ~ [[sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=75 | 32<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]]]]]] & ~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=100]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=100)
states: 325
abstracting: (32<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=75)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=100)
states: 325
abstracting: (80<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 58
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=59)
states: 325
abstracting: (32<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=75)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=100)
states: 325
abstracting: (80<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 58
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=59)
states: 325
abstracting: (32<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=75)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=100)
states: 325
abstracting: (80<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 58
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=59)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=84)
states: 325
.-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-13 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.228sec

checking: AF [[[AG [35<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)] | [[EF [~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=14]] & EG [~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]]] & sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=41]] & [[75<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1) | [EX [E [73<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) U sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]] & EF [~ [sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]] & AF [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]]]]
normalized: ~ [EG [~ [[[~ [EG [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]]] & [75<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1) | [EX [E [73<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) U sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]] & E [true U ~ [sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]]] & [[sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=41 & [E [true U ~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=14]] & EG [~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]]]] | ~ [E [true U ~ [35<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (35<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=14)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=41)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 235
abstracting: (73<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (75<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 166
....
EG iterations: 4

EG iterations: 0
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-03 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.175sec

checking: [E [76<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1) U ~ [[AX [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=97] & [[A [88<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1) U sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=37] | EX [33<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]] | AX [[sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=75 | sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=9]]]]]] & [EX [AG [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=42]] & EG [~ [[[EF [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)] & sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)] & sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=49]]]]]
normalized: [[EG [~ [[sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=49 & [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1) & E [true U sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]]] & EX [~ [E [true U ~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=42]]]]] & E [76<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1) U ~ [[[~ [EX [~ [[sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=75 | sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=9]]]] | [EX [33<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)] | [~ [EG [~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=37]]] & ~ [E [~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=37] U [~ [88<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)] & ~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=37]]]]]]] & ~ [EX [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=97]]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=97)
states: 325
.abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=37)
states: 325
abstracting: (88<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=37)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=37)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (33<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=9)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=75)
states: 325
.abstracting: (76<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=42)
states: 325
.abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 261
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 58
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=49)
states: 325
...
EG iterations: 3
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-12 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.240sec

checking: [E [[[sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=92 & [[45<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) & ~ [A [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=55 U sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=14]]] | EX [[sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=97 | sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=3]]]] & EG [[sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) | AF [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=49]]]] U [A [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=81 U sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=22] | ~ [EG [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)]]]] & EX [[EX [EG [A [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=69 U sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]]] & 64<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]]
normalized: [EX [[64<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) & EX [EG [[~ [E [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)] U [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)] & ~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=69]]]] & ~ [EG [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]] & E [[EG [[sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) | ~ [EG [~ [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=49]]]]] & [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=92 & [EX [[sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=97 | sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=3]] | [45<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) & ~ [[~ [EG [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=14]]] & ~ [E [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=14] U [~ [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=55] & ~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=14]]]]]]]]]] U [~ [EG [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)]] | [~ [EG [~ [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=22]]] & ~ [E [~ [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=22] U [~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=81] & ~ [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=22]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=22)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=81)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=22)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=22)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 276
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=14)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=55)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=14)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=14)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (45<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=3)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=97)
states: 325
.abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=92)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=49)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 313

EG iterations: 0
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 232
......
EG iterations: 6
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=69)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 232
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 232

EG iterations: 0
.abstracting: (64<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-09 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.320sec

checking: A [[~ [[EX [AX [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]] | A [AX [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)] U [E [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=16 U sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=50] & [sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) | sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]]]]] & EF [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=62]]] U [51<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) | AX [AG [~ [AF [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=76]]]]]]
normalized: [~ [EG [~ [[51<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) | ~ [EX [E [true U ~ [EG [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=76]]]]]]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [[51<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) | ~ [EX [E [true U ~ [EG [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=76]]]]]]]] U [~ [[E [true U ~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=62]] & ~ [[[~ [EG [~ [[[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) | sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)] & E [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=16 U sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=50]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [[[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) | sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)] & E [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=16 U sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=50]]] U [EX [~ [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]] & ~ [[[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) | sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)] & E [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=16 U sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=50]]]]]]] | EX [~ [EX [~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]] & ~ [[51<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) | ~ [EX [E [true U ~ [EG [~ [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=76]]]]]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=76)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
.abstracting: (51<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 261
..abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=50)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=16)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 19
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 265
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 130
.abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=50)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=16)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 19
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 265
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=50)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=16)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 19
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 265
.....
EG iterations: 5
abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=62)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=76)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
.abstracting: (51<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=76)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
.abstracting: (51<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
....
EG iterations: 4
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-10 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.207sec

checking: E [EG [E [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)] | sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)] U [[A [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=3 U sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=36] & 92<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)] & ~ [A [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=71 U sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=6]]]]] U EX [EX [[[[14<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1) | sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=14] & [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1) & sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]] & sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]]
normalized: E [EG [E [[sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) | ~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]] U [~ [[~ [EG [~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=6]]] & ~ [E [~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=6] U [~ [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=71] & ~ [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=6]]]]]] & [92<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) & [~ [EG [~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=36]]] & ~ [E [~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=36] U [~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=3] & ~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=36]]]]]]]]] U EX [EX [[sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) & [[sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1) & sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & [14<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1) | sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=14]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=14)
states: 325
abstracting: (14<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 130
..abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=36)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=3)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=36)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=36)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (92<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=71)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 247
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 235
.
EG iterations: 1
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-01 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.225sec

checking: ~ [[EF [~ [[47<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1) & EF [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=86]]]] | [AX [[E [EF [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)] U [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=57 | 63<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)]] | EG [EF [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)]]]] | [AG [EX [~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]]] & [AG [A [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1) U 16<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]] & A [EX [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=59] U EG [38<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]
normalized: ~ [[[[[[~ [EG [~ [EG [38<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]] & ~ [E [~ [EG [38<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]] U [~ [EG [38<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]] & ~ [EX [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=59]]]]]] & ~ [E [true U ~ [[~ [EG [~ [16<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]] & ~ [E [~ [16<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)] U [~ [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)] & ~ [16<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]]] & ~ [E [true U ~ [EX [~ [sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]]]]]] | ~ [EX [~ [[EG [E [true U sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)]] | E [E [true U sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)] U [sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=57 | 63<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)]]]]]]] | E [true U ~ [[47<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1) & E [true U sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=86]]]]]]

abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=86)
states: 325
abstracting: (47<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (63<=sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=57)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 325

EG iterations: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasLeft_Philosopher3, HasLeft_Philosopher2, HasLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 226
.abstracting: (16<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 235
abstracting: (16<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (16<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0

EG iterations: 0
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=59)
states: 325
.abstracting: (38<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (38<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (38<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.
EG iterations: 1

EG iterations: 0
-> the formula is FALSE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-05 FALSE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.223sec

checking: A [46<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1) U [A [~ [[AF [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & A [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) U sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6]]] U AX [[EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)] & ~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]] | ~ [[~ [[[EG [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)] | 5<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)] & 22<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)]] & [[sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=64 & [E [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) U 41<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)] | [sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=44 | sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=40]]] & [96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) | 74<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)]]]]]]
normalized: [~ [EG [~ [[~ [[[[96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) | 74<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)] & [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=64 & [[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=44 | sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=40] | E [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) U 41<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]]] & ~ [[22<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1) & [5<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) | EG [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)]]]]]] | [~ [EG [EX [~ [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]]]] & ~ [E [EX [~ [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]] U [[[~ [EG [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6]]] & ~ [E [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6] U [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6] & ~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]]] & ~ [EG [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]] & EX [~ [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]]]]]] & ~ [E [~ [[~ [[[[96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) | 74<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)] & [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=64 & [[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=44 | sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=40] | E [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) U 41<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]]] & ~ [[22<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1) & [5<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) | EG [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)]]]]]] | [~ [EG [EX [~ [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]]]] & ~ [E [EX [~ [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]] U [[[~ [EG [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6]]] & ~ [E [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6] U [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6] & ~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]]] & ~ [EG [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]] & EX [~ [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]]]] U [~ [46<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)] & ~ [[~ [[[[96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1) | 74<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)] & [sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=64 & [[sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=44 | sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=40] | E [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1) U 41<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)]]]] & ~ [[22<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1) & [5<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1) | EG [sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1)]]]]]] | [~ [EG [EX [~ [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]]]] & ~ [E [EX [~ [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]] U [[[~ [EG [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6]]] & ~ [E [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6] U [~ [sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6] & ~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)]]]]] & ~ [EG [~ [sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)]]]] & EX [~ [[~ [sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)] & EX [48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)]]]]]]]]]]]]]]

abstracting: (48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 265
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.abstracting: (48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.....
EG iterations: 4
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 276
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (5<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (22<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (41<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 276
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=40)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=44)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=64)
states: 325
abstracting: (74<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (46<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 265
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.abstracting: (48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.....
EG iterations: 4
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 276
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (5<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (22<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (41<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 276
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=40)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=44)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=64)
states: 325
abstracting: (74<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.abstracting: (sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 265
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1)<=6)
states: 325
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.abstracting: (48<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.abstracting: (sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1)<=sum(Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher3_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher2_Philosopher1, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher3, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher2, Neighbourhood_Philosopher1_Philosopher1))
states: 325
.....
EG iterations: 4
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitRight_Philosopher3, WaitRight_Philosopher2, WaitRight_Philosopher1))
states: 276
.
EG iterations: 1
abstracting: (5<=sum(Think_Philosopher3, Think_Philosopher2, Think_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (22<=sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (41<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1)<=sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1))
states: 276
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=40)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(Forks_Philosopher3, Forks_Philosopher2, Forks_Philosopher1)<=44)
states: 325
abstracting: (sum(WaitLeft_Philosopher3, WaitLeft_Philosopher2, WaitLeft_Philosopher1)<=64)
states: 325
abstracting: (74<=sum(Outside_Philosopher3, Outside_Philosopher2, Outside_Philosopher1))
states: 0
abstracting: (96<=sum(HasRight_Philosopher3, HasRight_Philosopher2, HasRight_Philosopher1))
states: 0
.
EG iterations: 1
-> the formula is TRUE

FORMULA PhilosophersDyn-COL-03-CTLCardinality-15 TRUE TECHNIQUES SEQUENTIAL_PROCESSING DECISION_DIAGRAMS UNFOLDING_TO_PT

MC time: 0m 0.267sec

totally nodes used: 33798 (3.4e+04)
number of garbage collections: 0
fire ops cache: hits/miss/sum: 95825 344837 440662
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 360107 66748757 16 1024MB
basic ops cache: hits/miss/sum: 17395 49589 66984
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 77404 16699812 12 192MB
unary ops cache: hits/miss/sum: 0 0 0
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 0 16777216 8 128MB
abstract ops cache: hits/miss/sum: 0 35308 35308
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 1 16777215 12 192MB
state nr cache: hits/miss/sum: 1006 3066 4072
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 3066 8385542 32 256MB
max state cache: hits/miss/sum: 0 0 0
used/not used/entry size/cache size: 0 8388608 32 256MB
uniqueHash elements/entry size/size: 67108864 4 256MB
0 67075919
1 32172
2 754
3 19
4 0
5 0
6 0
7 0
8 0
9 0
>= 10 0

Total processing time: 0m 7.539sec


BK_STOP 1678763916164

--------------------
content from stderr:

check for maximal unmarked siphon
ok
check for constant places
ok
check if there are places and transitions
ok
check if there are transitions without pre-places
ok
check if at least one transition is enabled in m0
ok
check if there are transitions that can never fire
ok


initing FirstDep: 0m 0.000sec


iterations count:1660 (19), effective:60 (0)

initing FirstDep: 0m 0.000sec


iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:397 (4), effective:11 (0)

iterations count:1364 (16), effective:51 (0)

iterations count:521 (6), effective:16 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:732 (8), effective:19 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:783 (9), effective:33 (0)

iterations count:1059 (12), effective:30 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:1364 (16), effective:51 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

iterations count:84 (1), effective:0 (0)

Sequence of Actions to be Executed by the VM

This is useful if one wants to reexecute the tool in the VM from the submitted image disk.

set -x
# this is for BenchKit: configuration of major elements for the test
export BK_INPUT="PhilosophersDyn-COL-03"
export BK_EXAMINATION="CTLCardinality"
export BK_TOOL="marcie"
export BK_RESULT_DIR="/tmp/BK_RESULTS/OUTPUTS"
export BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT="3600"
export BK_MEMORY_CONFINEMENT="16384"
export BK_BIN_PATH="/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/"

# this is specific to your benchmark or test

export BIN_DIR="$HOME/BenchKit/bin"

# remove the execution directoty if it exists (to avoid increse of .vmdk images)
if [ -d execution ] ; then
rm -rf execution
fi

# this is for BenchKit: explicit launching of the test
echo "====================================================================="
echo " Generated by BenchKit 2-5348"
echo " Executing tool marcie"
echo " Input is PhilosophersDyn-COL-03, examination is CTLCardinality"
echo " Time confinement is $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT seconds"
echo " Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes"
echo " Number of cores is 1"
echo " Run identifier is r289-tall-167873940200273"
echo "====================================================================="
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "preparation of the directory to be used:"

tar xzf /home/mcc/BenchKit/INPUTS/PhilosophersDyn-COL-03.tgz
mv PhilosophersDyn-COL-03 execution
cd execution
if [ "CTLCardinality" = "ReachabilityDeadlock" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "UpperBounds" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "QuasiLiveness" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "StableMarking" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "Liveness" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "OneSafe" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "StateSpace" ]; then
rm -f GenericPropertiesVerdict.xml
fi
pwd
ls -lh

echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stdout:"
echo
echo "=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)"
echo
if [ "CTLCardinality" = "UpperBounds" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of positive values"
echo NUM_VECTOR
elif [ "CTLCardinality" != "StateSpace" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of booleans"
echo BOOL_VECTOR
else
echo "no data necessary for post analysis"
fi
echo
if [ -f "CTLCardinality.txt" ] ; then
echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)"
for x in $(grep Property CTLCardinality.txt | cut -d ' ' -f 2 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
elif [ -f "CTLCardinality.xml" ] ; then # for cunf (txt files deleted;-)
echo echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from xml file)"
for x in $(grep '' CTLCardinality.xml | cut -d '>' -f 2 | cut -d '<' -f 1 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
elif [ "CTLCardinality" = "ReachabilityDeadlock" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "QuasiLiveness" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "StableMarking" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "Liveness" ] || [ "CTLCardinality" = "OneSafe" ] ; then
echo "FORMULA_NAME CTLCardinality"
fi
echo
echo "=== Now, execution of the tool begins"
echo
echo -n "BK_START "
date -u +%s%3N
echo
timeout -s 9 $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT bash -c "/home/mcc/BenchKit/BenchKit_head.sh 2> STDERR ; echo ; echo -n \"BK_STOP \" ; date -u +%s%3N"
if [ $? -eq 137 ] ; then
echo
echo "BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT_REACHED"
fi
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stderr:"
echo
cat STDERR ;