About the Execution of ITS-Tools for Sudoku-PT-AN04
| Execution Summary | |||||
| Max Memory Used (MB) |
Time wait (ms) | CPU Usage (ms) | I/O Wait (ms) | Computed Result | Execution Status |
| 780.848 | 45139.00 | 59338.00 | 474.00 | FTFTTFFFFFFFTFTF | normal |
Execution Chart
We display below the execution chart for this examination (boot time has been removed).
Trace from the execution
Formatting '/data/fkordon/mcc2021-input.r254-tall-162106746200581.qcow2', fmt=qcow2 size=4294967296 backing_file='/data/fkordon/mcc2021-input.qcow2' encryption=off cluster_size=65536 lazy_refcounts=off
Waiting for the VM to be ready (probing ssh)
.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
=====================================================================
Generated by BenchKit 2-4028
Executing tool itstools
Input is Sudoku-PT-AN04, examination is LTLFireability
Time confinement is 3600 seconds
Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes
Number of cores is 4
Run identifier is r254-tall-162106746200581
=====================================================================
--------------------
preparation of the directory to be used:
/home/mcc/execution
total 1.6M
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 88K May 15 08:50 CTLCardinality.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 465K May 15 08:50 CTLCardinality.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 76K May 15 08:50 CTLFireability.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 391K May 15 08:50 CTLFireability.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 4.2K May 6 14:48 GenericPropertiesDefinition.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 6.6K May 6 14:48 GenericPropertiesVerdict.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 24K Mar 28 16:44 LTLCardinality.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 97K Mar 28 16:44 LTLCardinality.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 30K Mar 28 16:44 LTLFireability.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 116K Mar 28 16:44 LTLFireability.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 20K May 13 19:29 ReachabilityCardinality.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 67K May 13 19:29 ReachabilityCardinality.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 35K May 13 19:29 ReachabilityFireability.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 130K May 13 19:29 ReachabilityFireability.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 1.6K Mar 22 08:16 UpperBounds.txt
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 3.3K Mar 22 08:16 UpperBounds.xml
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 5 May 5 16:52 equiv_col
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 5 May 5 16:52 instance
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 6 May 5 16:52 iscolored
-rw-r--r-- 1 mcc users 44K May 5 16:52 model.pnml
--------------------
content from stdout:
=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)
The expected result is a vector of booleans
BOOL_VECTOR
here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-00
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-01
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-02
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-03
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-04
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-05
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-06
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-07
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-08
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-09
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-10
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-11
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-12
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-13
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-14
FORMULA_NAME Sudoku-PT-AN04-15
=== Now, execution of the tool begins
BK_START 1621233354069
Running Version 0
[2021-05-17 06:35:55] [INFO ] Running its-tools with arguments : [-pnfolder, /home/mcc/execution, -examination, LTLFireability, -spotpath, /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltlfilt, -z3path, /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//z3/bin/z3, -yices2path, /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//yices/bin/yices, -its, -ltsmin, -greatspnpath, /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//greatspn/, -order, META, -manyOrder, -smt, -timeout, 3600]
[2021-05-17 06:35:55] [INFO ] Parsing pnml file : /home/mcc/execution/model.pnml
[2021-05-17 06:35:55] [INFO ] Load time of PNML (sax parser for PT used): 39 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:55] [INFO ] Transformed 112 places.
[2021-05-17 06:35:55] [INFO ] Transformed 64 transitions.
[2021-05-17 06:35:55] [INFO ] Parsed PT model containing 112 places and 64 transitions in 78 ms.
Parsed 16 properties from file /home/mcc/execution/LTLFireability.xml in 20 ms.
Working with output stream class java.io.PrintStream
[2021-05-17 06:35:55] [INFO ] Initial state test concluded for 3 properties.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-02 FALSE TECHNIQUES TOPOLOGICAL INITIAL_STATE
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-04 TRUE TECHNIQUES TOPOLOGICAL INITIAL_STATE
Support contains 48 out of 112 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 112/112 places, 64/64 transitions.
Reduce places removed 64 places and 0 transitions.
Iterating post reduction 0 with 64 rules applied. Total rules applied 64 place count 48 transition count 64
Applied a total of 64 rules in 18 ms. Remains 48 /112 variables (removed 64) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 13 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 83 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 9 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 63 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 171 ms to find 0 implicit places.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 11 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 66 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/112 places, 64/64 transitions.
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Initial state reduction rules for LTL removed 1 formulas.
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 34 ms
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-06 FALSE TECHNIQUES TOPOLOGICAL INITIAL_STATE
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-01 TRUE TECHNIQUES TOPOLOGICAL INITIAL_STATE
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 17 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Input system was already deterministic with 64 transitions.
Finished random walk after 13 steps, including 1 resets, run visited all 18 properties in 3 ms. (steps per millisecond=4 )
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(X(F((F(p1)&&p0))))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 48 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 1 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 2 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 19 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 38 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 59 ms to find 0 implicit places.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:56] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 56 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 220 ms :[(OR (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), (NOT p1), (OR (NOT p0) (NOT p1))]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-00 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 2}], [{ cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={0} source=1 dest: 1}], [{ cond=(AND p0 (NOT p1)), acceptance={0} source=2 dest: 1}, { cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={0} source=2 dest: 2}]], initial=0, aps=[p1:(OR (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s35 1))), p0:(AND (OR (LT s1 1) (LT s17 1) (LT s37 1)) (OR (LT s10 1) (LT s26 1) (LT s42 1)) (OR (LT s12 1) (LT s31 1) (LT s44 1)) (OR (LT s9 1) (LT s24 1) (LT s33 1)) (OR (LT s10 1) (LT s27 1) (LT s46 1)) (OR (LT s12 1) (LT s29 1) (LT s36 1)) (OR (LT s1 1) (LT s19 1) (LT s45 1)) (OR (LT s0 1) (LT s16 1) (LT s32 1)) (OR (LT s9 1) (LT s25 1) (LT s37 1)) (OR (LT s7 1) (LT s21 1) (LT s39 1)) (OR (LT s2 1) (LT s18 1) (LT s42 1)) (OR (LT s1 1) (LT s16 1) (LT s33 1)) (OR (LT s7 1) (LT s22 1) (LT s43 1)) (OR (LT s13 1) (LT s31 1) (LT s45 1)) (OR (LT s12 1) (LT s30 1) (LT s40 1)) (OR (LT s2 1) (LT s17 1) (LT s38 1)) (OR (LT s7 1) (LT s23 1) (LT s47 1)) (OR (LT s8 1) (LT s24 1) (LT s32 1)) (OR (LT s4 1) (LT s21 1) (LT s36 1)) (OR (LT s9 1) (LT s27 1) (LT s45 1)) (OR (LT s15 1) (LT s29 1) (LT s39 1)) (OR (LT s4 1) (LT s20 1) (LT s32 1)) (OR (LT s9 1) (LT s26 1) (LT s41 1)) (OR (LT s8 1) (LT s25 1) (LT s36 1)) (OR (LT s6 1) (LT s21 1) (LT s38 1)) (OR (LT s15 1) (LT s28 1) (LT s35 1)) (OR (LT s14 1) (LT s28 1) (LT s34 1)) (OR (LT s8 1) (LT s26 1) (LT s40 1)) (OR (LT s5 1) (LT s21 1) (LT s37 1)) (OR (LT s3 1) (LT s17 1) (LT s39 1)) (OR (LT s2 1) (LT s16 1) (LT s34 1)) (OR (LT s6 1) (LT s22 1) (LT s42 1)) (OR (LT s8 1) (LT s27 1) (LT s44 1)) (OR (LT s3 1) (LT s16 1) (LT s35 1)) (OR (LT s5 1) (LT s20 1) (LT s33 1)) (OR (LT s6 1) (LT s23 1) (LT s46 1)) (OR (LT s14 1) (LT s30 1) (LT s42 1)) (OR (LT s15 1) (LT s31 1) (LT s47 1)) (OR (LT s3 1) (LT s18 1) (LT s43 1)) (OR (LT s11 1) (LT s24 1) (LT s35 1)) (OR (LT s13 1) (LT s28 1) (LT s33 1)) (OR (LT s0 1) (LT s19 1) (LT s44 1)) (OR (LT s5 1) (LT s22 1) (LT s41 1)) (OR (LT s3 1) (LT s19 1) (LT s47 1)) (OR (LT s15 1) (LT s30 1) (LT s43 1)) (OR (LT s14 1) (LT s29 1) (LT s38 1)) (OR (LT s11 1) (LT s26 1) (LT s43 1)) (OR (LT s0 1) (LT s18 1) (LT s40 1)) (OR (LT s13 1) (LT s30 1) (LT s41 1)) (OR (LT s6 1) (LT s20 1) (LT s34 1)) (OR (LT s5 1) (LT s23 1) (LT s45 1)) (OR (LT s13 1) (LT s29 1) (LT s37 1)) (OR (LT s11 1) (LT s25 1) (LT s39 1)) (OR (LT s10 1) (LT s24 1) (LT s34 1)) (OR (LT s11 1) (LT s27 1) (LT s47 1)) (OR (LT s4 1) (LT s22 1) (LT s40 1)) (OR (LT s14 1) (LT s31 1) (LT s46 1)) (OR (LT s2 1) (LT s19 1) (LT s46 1)) (OR (LT s10 1) (LT s25 1) (LT s38 1)) (OR (LT s0 1) (LT s17 1) (LT s36 1)) (OR (LT s12 1) (LT s28 1) (LT s32 1)) (OR (LT s4 1) (LT s23 1) (LT s44 1)) (OR (LT s1 1) (LT s18 1) (LT s41 1)) (OR (LT s7 1) (LT s20 1) (LT s35 1)))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, deterministic, no-univ-branch, unambiguous, semi-deterministic, very-weak, weak, inherently-weak], stateDesc=[null, null, null][false, false, false]]
Stuttering criterion allowed to conclude after 12 steps with 0 reset in 2 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-00 FALSE TECHNIQUES STUTTER_TEST
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-00 finished in 382 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !((G((X(p1)||p0)) U X(p1)))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 48 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 0 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:35:57] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 5 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:57] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 21 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:35:57] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 4 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:57] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 33 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 56 ms to find 0 implicit places.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:35:57] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:35:57] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 40 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 114 ms :[(NOT p1), (NOT p1), (NOT p1), true, (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p1))]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-03 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={} source=0 dest: 1}, { cond=p0, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 2}], [{ cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={} source=1 dest: 3}], [{ cond=(AND (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), acceptance={0} source=2 dest: 1}, { cond=(AND p0 (NOT p1)), acceptance={0} source=2 dest: 2}, { cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={0} source=2 dest: 4}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={0} source=3 dest: 3}], [{ cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={} source=4 dest: 1}, { cond=true, acceptance={} source=4 dest: 4}]], initial=0, aps=[p0:(OR (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s35 1))), p1:(OR (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s35 1)))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, no-univ-branch, very-weak, weak, inherently-weak], stateDesc=[null, null, null, null, null][false, false, false, false, false]]
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 50000 reset in 612 ms.
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 50000 reset in 564 ms.
Complete graph has no SCC; deadlocks are unavoidable. place count 48 transition count 64
Detected that all paths lead to deadlock. Applying this knowledge to assert that all AP eventually converge : F ( (Ga|G!a) & (Gb|G!b)...)
Knowledge obtained : [(F (G (NOT p0))), (F (G (NOT p1))), p0, p1]
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 100 ms :[(NOT p1), (NOT p1), (NOT p1), true, (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p1))]
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 50000 reset in 537 ms.
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 50000 reset in 533 ms.
Applying partial POR strategy [false, true, false, true, false]
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 105 ms :[(NOT p1), (NOT p1), (NOT p1), true, (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p1))]
Support contains 48 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Property had overlarge support with respect to TGBA, discarding it for now.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 2 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
[2021-05-17 06:36:00] [INFO ] Redundant transitions in 1 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:00] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 14 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:00] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 61 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 50000 reset in 518 ms.
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 50000 reset in 518 ms.
[2021-05-17 06:36:01] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 8 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:01] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 6 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:01] [INFO ] Time to serialize gal into /tmp/LTL14849628051023834684.gal : 2 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:01] [INFO ] Time to serialize properties into /tmp/LTL11602500651910112050.ltl : 4 ms
Invoking ITS tools like this :CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.itstools.binaries_1.0.0.202104292328/bin/its-ltl-linux64, --gc-threshold, 2000000, -i, /tmp/LTL14849628051023834684.gal, -t, CGAL, -LTL, /tmp/LTL11602500651910112050.ltl, -c, -stutter-deadlock, --gen-order, FOLLOW], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
its-ltl command run as :
/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.itstools.binaries_1.0.0.202104292328/bin/its-ltl-linux64 --gc-threshold 2000000 -i /tmp/LTL14849628051023834684.gal -t CGAL -LTL /tmp/LTL11602500651910112050.ltl -c -stutter-deadlock --gen-order FOLLOW
Read 1 LTL properties
Checking formula 0 : !(((G(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((X("((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))"))||("(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1))"))||("(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1))"))||("(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1))")))U(X("((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))"))))
Formula 0 simplified : !(G("(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1))" | "(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1))" | X"((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))") U X"((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_2_1>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_0>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_0_3>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_3>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_2>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_1_1>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((Rows_3_1>=1)&&(Cells_3_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_3>=1)&&(Cells_2_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_2>=1)&&(Cells_3_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_2>=1)&&(Cells_0_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((Rows_2_2>=1)&&(Cells_2_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((Rows_0_0>=1)&&(Cells_0_1>=1))&&(Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((Rows_3_0>=1)&&(Cells_3_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((Rows_1_0>=1)&&(Cells_1_3>=1))&&(Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((Rows_0_1>=1)&&(Cells_0_2>=1))&&(Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((Rows_1_3>=1)&&(Cells_1_0>=1))&&(Columns_0_3>=1)))")
Detected timeout of ITS tools.
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 7 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Applying decomposition
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 6 ms
Converted graph to binary with : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.louvain.binaries_1.0.0.202104292328/bin/convert-linux64, -i, /tmp/graph526974790535593585.txt, -o, /tmp/graph526974790535593585.bin, -w, /tmp/graph526974790535593585.weights], workingDir=null]
Built communities with : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.louvain.binaries_1.0.0.202104292328/bin/louvain-linux64, /tmp/graph526974790535593585.bin, -l, -1, -v, -w, /tmp/graph526974790535593585.weights, -q, 0, -e, 0.001], workingDir=null]
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Decomposing Gal with order
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Rewriting arrays to variables to allow decomposition.
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Removed a total of 144 redundant transitions.
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Flatten gal took : 50 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Fuse similar labels procedure discarded/fused a total of 0 labels/synchronizations in 1 ms.
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Time to serialize gal into /tmp/LTL10921019711301794868.gal : 13 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:16] [INFO ] Time to serialize properties into /tmp/LTL17387068354158174930.ltl : 4 ms
Invoking ITS tools like this :CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.itstools.binaries_1.0.0.202104292328/bin/its-ltl-linux64, --gc-threshold, 2000000, -i, /tmp/LTL10921019711301794868.gal, -t, CGAL, -LTL, /tmp/LTL17387068354158174930.ltl, -c, -stutter-deadlock], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
its-ltl command run as :
/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.itstools.binaries_1.0.0.202104292328/bin/its-ltl-linux64 --gc-threshold 2000000 -i /tmp/LTL10921019711301794868.gal -t CGAL -LTL /tmp/LTL17387068354158174930.ltl -c -stutter-deadlock
Read 1 LTL properties
Checking formula 0 : !(((G(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((X("((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))"))||("(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))"))||("(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1))"))||("(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1))"))||("(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1))"))||("(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1))"))||("(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1))"))||("(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1))"))||("(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1))"))||("(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))"))||("(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1))"))||("(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1))"))||("(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1))"))||("(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1))"))||("(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1))"))||("(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1))"))||("(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1))"))||("(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1))"))||("(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1))"))||("(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1))"))||("(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1))"))||("(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1))"))||("(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1))"))||("(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1))"))||("(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1))"))||("(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1))"))||("(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1))"))||("(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1))"))||("(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1))"))||("(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))"))||("(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1))"))||("(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1))"))||("(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1))"))||("(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1))"))||("(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1))"))||("(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1))"))||("(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1))"))||("(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1))"))||("(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1))"))||("(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1))"))||("(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1))"))||("(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1))"))||("(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1))"))||("(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1))"))||("(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1))"))||("(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1))"))||("(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1))"))||("(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1))"))||("(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1))"))||("(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1))"))||("(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1))"))||("(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1))"))||("(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))"))||("(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1))"))||("(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1))"))||("(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1))"))||("(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1))"))||("(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1))"))||("(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1))"))||("(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1))"))||("(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1))"))||("(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1))"))||("(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1))"))||("(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1))"))||("(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1))")))U(X("((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))"))))
Formula 0 simplified : !(G("(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1))" | "(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1))" | "(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1))" | "(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1))" | "(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1))" | "(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))" | "(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1))" | "(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1))" | "(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1))" | "(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1))" | "(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1))" | "(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1))" | "(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1))" | "(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1))" | "(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1))" | "(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1))" | "(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1))" | "(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1))" | "(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1))" | "(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1))" | "(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1))" | "(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))" | "(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1))" | "(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1))" | "(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1))" | "(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1))" | "(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1))" | "(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1))" | "(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1))" | "(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1))" | "(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1))" | "(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1))" | "(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1))" | "(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1))" | "(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1))" | "(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1))" | "(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1))" | "(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))" | "(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1))" | "(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1))" | "(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1))" | "(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1))" | "(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1))" | "(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1))" | "(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1))" | "(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1))" | "(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1))" | "(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1))" | "(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1))" | "(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1))" | "(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1))" | "(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1))" | "(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1))" | "(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))" | "(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1))" | "(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1))" | "(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1))" | "(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1))" | "(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1))" | "(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1))" | "(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1))" | "(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1))" | "(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1))" | "(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1))" | X"((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))") U X"((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u9.Rows_2_1>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u21.Cells_1_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u8.Rows_2_0>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u16.Cells_0_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u42.Columns_2_2>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u33.Columns_0_1>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u3.Rows_0_3>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u15.Rows_3_3>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u26.Cells_2_2>=1))&&(u43.Columns_2_3>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u30.Cells_3_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u6.Rows_1_2>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u5.Rows_1_1>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u45.Columns_3_1>=1)))||(((u13.Rows_3_1>=1)&&(u29.Cells_3_1>=1))&&(u37.Columns_1_1>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u39.Columns_1_3>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u24.Cells_2_0>=1))&&(u34.Columns_0_2>=1)))||(((u11.Rows_2_3>=1)&&(u27.Cells_2_3>=1))&&(u47.Columns_3_3>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u22.Cells_1_2>=1))&&(u40.Columns_2_0>=1)))||(((u14.Rows_3_2>=1)&&(u31.Cells_3_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u2.Rows_0_2>=1)&&(u19.Cells_0_3>=1))&&(u46.Columns_3_2>=1)))||(((u10.Rows_2_2>=1)&&(u25.Cells_2_1>=1))&&(u38.Columns_1_2>=1)))||(((u0.Rows_0_0>=1)&&(u17.Cells_0_1>=1))&&(u36.Columns_1_0>=1)))||(((u12.Rows_3_0>=1)&&(u28.Cells_3_0>=1))&&(u32.Columns_0_0>=1)))||(((u4.Rows_1_0>=1)&&(u23.Cells_1_3>=1))&&(u44.Columns_3_0>=1)))||(((u1.Rows_0_1>=1)&&(u18.Cells_0_2>=1))&&(u41.Columns_2_1>=1)))||(((u7.Rows_1_3>=1)&&(u20.Cells_1_0>=1))&&(u35.Columns_0_3>=1)))")
Detected timeout of ITS tools.
Built C files in :
/tmp/ltsmin6928695267878546463
[2021-05-17 06:36:31] [INFO ] Built C files in 29ms conformant to PINS (ltsmin variant)in folder :/tmp/ltsmin6928695267878546463
Running compilation step : CommandLine [args=[gcc, -c, -I/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.ltsmin.binaries_1.0.0.202104292328/bin/include/, -I., -std=c99, -fPIC, -O2, model.c], workingDir=/tmp/ltsmin6928695267878546463]
Compilation finished in 518 ms.
Running link step : CommandLine [args=[gcc, -shared, -o, gal.so, model.o], workingDir=/tmp/ltsmin6928695267878546463]
Link finished in 40 ms.
Running LTSmin : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.ltsmin.binaries_1.0.0.202104292328/bin/pins2lts-mc-linux64, ./gal.so, --threads=8, --when, --ltl, ([]((X((LTLAPp1==true))||(LTLAPp0==true))) U X((LTLAPp1==true))), --buchi-type=spotba], workingDir=/tmp/ltsmin6928695267878546463]
LTSmin run took 597 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-03 TRUE TECHNIQUES EXPLICIT LTSMIN SAT_SMT
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-03 finished in 35707 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(X(X(G(!p0))))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 48 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 1 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:32] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:32] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 13 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:32] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 0 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:32] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 31 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 46 ms to find 0 implicit places.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:32] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 0 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:32] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 52 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 100 ms :[true, p0, p0, p0]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-05 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=true, acceptance={0} source=0 dest: 0}], [{ cond=p0, acceptance={} source=1 dest: 0}, { cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={} source=1 dest: 1}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=2 dest: 1}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=3 dest: 2}]], initial=3, aps=[p0:(OR (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s35 1)))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, complete, deterministic, no-univ-branch, unambiguous, semi-deterministic, terminal, very-weak, weak, inherently-weak], stateDesc=[null, null, null, null][false, false, false, false]]
Entered a terminal (fully accepting) state of product in 2 steps with 0 reset in 1 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-05 FALSE TECHNIQUES STUTTER_TEST
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-05 finished in 209 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(F(G(p0)))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 48 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 6 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:32] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:32] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 16 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:32] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 54 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 71 ms to find 0 implicit places.
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Redundant transitions in 1 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 58 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 26 ms :[(NOT p0)]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-07 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={0} source=0 dest: 0}, { cond=p0, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 0}]], initial=0, aps=[p0:(OR (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s42 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s35 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s3 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s15 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s43 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s30 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s6 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s5 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s45 1)) (AND (GEQ s13 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s37 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s39 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s34 1)) (AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s47 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s40 1)) (AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s31 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s19 1) (GEQ s46 1)) (AND (GEQ s10 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s38 1)) (AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s36 1)) (AND (GEQ s12 1) (GEQ s28 1) (GEQ s32 1)) (AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s23 1) (GEQ s44 1)) (AND (GEQ s1 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s41 1)) (AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s20 1) (GEQ s35 1)))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, complete, deterministic, no-univ-branch, unambiguous, semi-deterministic, stutter-invariant], stateDesc=[null][true]]
Stuttering criterion allowed to conclude after 16 steps with 0 reset in 0 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-07 FALSE TECHNIQUES STUTTER_TEST
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-07 finished in 180 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(G((F(p0)&&F(G(p1)))))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 6 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 3 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 53 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 84 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 138 ms to find 0 implicit places.
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Redundant transitions in 2 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 9 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 55 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 106 ms :[(OR (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), (NOT p0), (NOT p1)]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-08 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 0}, { cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={} source=0 dest: 1}, { cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={} source=0 dest: 2}], [{ cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={0} source=1 dest: 1}], [{ cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={0} source=2 dest: 2}, { cond=p1, acceptance={} source=2 dest: 2}]], initial=0, aps=[p0:(AND (GEQ s4 1) (GEQ s21 1) (GEQ s36 1)), p1:(AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s40 1))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, no-univ-branch, stutter-invariant], stateDesc=[null, null, null][true, true, true]]
Stuttering criterion allowed to conclude after 14 steps with 0 reset in 0 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-08 FALSE TECHNIQUES STUTTER_TEST
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-08 finished in 321 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(X(F(p0)))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 3 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 2 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 63 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 0 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 81 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 146 ms to find 0 implicit places.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 87 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 47 ms :[(NOT p0), (NOT p0)]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-09 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 1}], [{ cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={0} source=1 dest: 1}]], initial=0, aps=[p0:(AND (GEQ s0 1) (GEQ s16 1) (GEQ s32 1))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, deterministic, no-univ-branch, unambiguous, semi-deterministic, very-weak, weak, inherently-weak], stateDesc=[null, null][false, false]]
Stuttering criterion allowed to conclude after 22 steps with 4 reset in 1 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-09 FALSE TECHNIQUES STUTTER_TEST
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-09 finished in 302 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(X(X(X(G((F(p1)&&p0))))))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 5 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 2 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 30 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 49 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 80 ms to find 0 implicit places.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 7 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:33] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 40 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 143 ms :[(OR (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), (OR (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), (OR (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), (OR (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), true, (NOT p1)]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-10 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 1}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=1 dest: 2}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=2 dest: 3}], [{ cond=p0, acceptance={} source=3 dest: 3}, { cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={} source=3 dest: 4}, { cond=(AND p0 (NOT p1)), acceptance={} source=3 dest: 5}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={0} source=4 dest: 4}], [{ cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={0} source=5 dest: 5}]], initial=0, aps=[p0:(AND (GEQ s14 1) (GEQ s29 1) (GEQ s38 1)), p1:(AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s17 1) (GEQ s38 1))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, no-univ-branch, very-weak, weak, inherently-weak], stateDesc=[null, null, null, null, null, null][false, false, false, false, false, false]]
Stuttering criterion allowed to conclude after 14 steps with 0 reset in 0 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-10 FALSE TECHNIQUES STUTTER_TEST
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-10 finished in 275 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(G((F(p0)&&F(p1))))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 6 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 3 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 0 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 45 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 58 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 105 ms to find 0 implicit places.
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Redundant transitions in 1 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 32 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 69 ms :[(OR (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), (NOT p0), (NOT p1)]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-11 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 0}, { cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={} source=0 dest: 1}, { cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={} source=0 dest: 2}], [{ cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={0} source=1 dest: 1}], [{ cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={0} source=2 dest: 2}]], initial=0, aps=[p0:(OR (LT s8 1) (LT s27 1) (LT s44 1)), p1:(OR (AND (GEQ s9 1) (GEQ s24 1) (GEQ s33 1)) (AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s27 1) (GEQ s44 1)))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, no-univ-branch, stutter-invariant, very-weak, weak, inherently-weak], stateDesc=[null, null, null][true, true, true]]
Stuttering criterion allowed to conclude after 138 steps with 18 reset in 1 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-11 FALSE TECHNIQUES STUTTER_TEST
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-11 finished in 236 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(X(F((G(p0)||(F(p1) U p2)))))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 6 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Property had overlarge support with respect to TGBA, discarding it for now.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 2 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 28 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 49 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 79 ms to find 0 implicit places.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 0 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:34] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 34 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 46 ms :[(AND (NOT p0) (NOT p2)), (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p2))]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-12 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=(AND (NOT p0) (NOT p2)), acceptance={0} source=0 dest: 0}, { cond=(AND p0 (NOT p2)), acceptance={} source=0 dest: 0}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=1 dest: 0}]], initial=1, aps=[p0:(AND (GEQ s8 1) (GEQ s25 1) (GEQ s36 1)), p2:(OR (LT s3 1) (LT s18 1) (LT s43 1))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, deterministic, no-univ-branch, unambiguous, semi-deterministic], stateDesc=[null, null][false, false]]
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 16863 reset in 605 ms.
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 16980 reset in 715 ms.
Complete graph has no SCC; deadlocks are unavoidable. place count 48 transition count 64
Detected that all paths lead to deadlock. Applying this knowledge to assert that all AP eventually converge : F ( (Ga|G!a) & (Gb|G!b)...)
Knowledge obtained : [(F (G (NOT p0))), (F (G p2)), p0, (NOT p2)]
Property proved to be true thanks to knowledge :(F (G p2))
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-12 TRUE TECHNIQUES STRUCTURAL INITIAL_STATE
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-12 finished in 1579 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(G((F(G(p1))&&p0)))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 6 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 2 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:35] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 0 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:35] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 33 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:35] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 0 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:35] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 54 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 94 ms to find 0 implicit places.
[2021-05-17 06:36:35] [INFO ] Redundant transitions in 0 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:35] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:35] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 29 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 65 ms :[(OR (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), true, (NOT p1)]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-13 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=p0, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 0}, { cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={} source=0 dest: 1}, { cond=(AND p0 (NOT p1)), acceptance={} source=0 dest: 2}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={0} source=1 dest: 1}], [{ cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={0} source=2 dest: 2}, { cond=p1, acceptance={} source=2 dest: 2}]], initial=0, aps=[p0:(AND (GEQ s7 1) (GEQ s22 1) (GEQ s43 1)), p1:(OR (LT s12 1) (LT s28 1) (LT s32 1))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, complete, no-univ-branch, stutter-invariant], stateDesc=[null, null, null][true, true, true]]
Entered a terminal (fully accepting) state of product in 47 steps with 3 reset in 1 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-13 FALSE TECHNIQUES STUTTER_TEST
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-13 finished in 205 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(X((X(X(F(p0)))||G((p1&&(F(p0)||p2))))))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 6 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 2 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:36] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:36] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 54 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:36] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 0 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:36] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 46 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 100 ms to find 0 implicit places.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:36] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 0 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:36] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 29 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 172 ms :[(OR (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p1)) (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p2))), (OR (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p1)) (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p2))), (NOT p0), (OR (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p2)) (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p1))), (NOT p0), (OR (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p2)) (AND (NOT p0) (NOT p1)))]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-14 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 1}], [{ cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={} source=1 dest: 2}, { cond=p1, acceptance={} source=1 dest: 3}, { cond=(AND p1 (NOT p2) (NOT p0)), acceptance={} source=1 dest: 4}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={} source=2 dest: 4}], [{ cond=(OR (NOT p1) (AND (NOT p2) (NOT p0))), acceptance={} source=3 dest: 4}, { cond=(OR (AND p1 p2) (AND p1 p0)), acceptance={} source=3 dest: 5}], [{ cond=(NOT p0), acceptance={0} source=4 dest: 4}], [{ cond=(OR (AND (NOT p1) (NOT p0)) (AND (NOT p2) (NOT p0))), acceptance={} source=5 dest: 4}, { cond=(AND p1 p2 (NOT p0)), acceptance={} source=5 dest: 5}]], initial=0, aps=[p1:(OR (LT s14 1) (LT s29 1) (LT s38 1)), p2:(OR (LT s14 1) (LT s29 1) (LT s38 1)), p0:(OR (LT s5 1) (LT s21 1) (LT s37 1))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, no-univ-branch, very-weak, weak, inherently-weak], stateDesc=[null, null, null, null, null, null][false, false, false, false, false, false]]
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 15780 reset in 571 ms.
Product exploration explored 100000 steps with 15761 reset in 591 ms.
Complete graph has no SCC; deadlocks are unavoidable. place count 48 transition count 64
Detected that all paths lead to deadlock. Applying this knowledge to assert that all AP eventually converge : F ( (Ga|G!a) & (Gb|G!b)...)
Knowledge obtained : [(F (G p1)), (F (G p2)), (F (G p0)), (NOT p1), (NOT p2), (NOT p0)]
Property proved to be true thanks to knowledge :(F (G p0))
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-14 TRUE TECHNIQUES STRUCTURAL INITIAL_STATE
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-14 finished in 1634 ms.
Running Spot : CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltl2tgba, --hoaf=tv, -f, !(G((p0||G(p1))))], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
Support contains 6 out of 48 places. Attempting structural reductions.
Starting structural reductions, iteration 0 : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Applied a total of 0 rules in 3 ms. Remains 48 /48 variables (removed 0) and now considering 64/64 (removed 0) transitions.
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:37] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:37] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants in 28 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:37] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:37] [INFO ] Implicit Places using invariants and state equation in 56 ms returned []
Implicit Place search using SMT with State Equation took 85 ms to find 0 implicit places.
[2021-05-17 06:36:37] [INFO ] Redundant transitions in 0 ms returned []
// Phase 1: matrix 64 rows 48 cols
[2021-05-17 06:36:37] [INFO ] Computed 11 place invariants in 1 ms
[2021-05-17 06:36:37] [INFO ] Dead Transitions using invariants and state equation in 30 ms returned []
Finished structural reductions, in 1 iterations. Remains : 48/48 places, 64/64 transitions.
Stuttering acceptance computed with spot in 54 ms :[(NOT p1), (AND (NOT p1) (NOT p0)), true]
Running random walk in product with property : Sudoku-PT-AN04-15 automaton TGBA [mat=[[{ cond=p1, acceptance={} source=0 dest: 0}, { cond=(NOT p1), acceptance={} source=0 dest: 2}], [{ cond=(AND (NOT p0) p1), acceptance={} source=1 dest: 0}, { cond=p0, acceptance={} source=1 dest: 1}, { cond=(AND (NOT p0) (NOT p1)), acceptance={} source=1 dest: 2}], [{ cond=true, acceptance={0} source=2 dest: 2}]], initial=1, aps=[p1:(AND (GEQ s2 1) (GEQ s18 1) (GEQ s42 1)), p0:(AND (GEQ s11 1) (GEQ s26 1) (GEQ s43 1))], nbAcceptance=1, properties=[trans-labels, explicit-labels, trans-acc, complete, deterministic, no-univ-branch, unambiguous, semi-deterministic, stutter-invariant, terminal, very-weak, weak, inherently-weak], stateDesc=[null, null, null][true, true, true]]
Entered a terminal (fully accepting) state of product in 6 steps with 0 reset in 0 ms.
FORMULA Sudoku-PT-AN04-15 FALSE TECHNIQUES STUTTER_TEST
Treatment of property Sudoku-PT-AN04-15 finished in 185 ms.
All properties solved without resorting to model-checking.
BK_STOP 1621233399208
--------------------
content from stderr:
+ export BINDIR=/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//../
+ BINDIR=/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//../
++ pwd
+ export MODEL=/home/mcc/execution
+ MODEL=/home/mcc/execution
+ [[ LTLFireability = StateSpace ]]
+ /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//runeclipse.sh /home/mcc/execution LTLFireability -its -ltsmin -greatspnpath /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//greatspn/ -order META -manyOrder -smt -timeout 3600
+ ulimit -s 65536
+ [[ -z '' ]]
+ export LTSMIN_MEM_SIZE=8589934592
+ LTSMIN_MEM_SIZE=8589934592
++ cut -d . -f 9
++ ls /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//itstools/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.application.pnmcc_1.0.0.202104292328.jar
+ VERSION=0
+ echo 'Running Version 0'
+ /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//itstools/its-tools -data /home/mcc/execution/workspace -pnfolder /home/mcc/execution -examination LTLFireability -spotpath /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//ltlfilt -z3path /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//z3/bin/z3 -yices2path /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//yices/bin/yices -its -ltsmin -greatspnpath /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin//..//greatspn/ -order META -manyOrder -smt -timeout 3600 -vmargs -Dosgi.locking=none -Declipse.stateSaveDelayInterval=-1 -Dosgi.configuration.area=/tmp/.eclipse -Xss128m -Xms40m -Xmx16000m
Sequence of Actions to be Executed by the VM
This is useful if one wants to reexecute the tool in the VM from the submitted image disk.
set -x
# this is for BenchKit: configuration of major elements for the test
export BK_INPUT="Sudoku-PT-AN04"
export BK_EXAMINATION="LTLFireability"
export BK_TOOL="itstools"
export BK_RESULT_DIR="/tmp/BK_RESULTS/OUTPUTS"
export BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT="3600"
export BK_MEMORY_CONFINEMENT="16384"
export BK_BIN_PATH="/home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/"
# this is specific to your benchmark or test
export BIN_DIR="$HOME/BenchKit/bin"
# remove the execution directoty if it exists (to avoid increse of .vmdk images)
if [ -d execution ] ; then
rm -rf execution
fi
# this is for BenchKit: explicit launching of the test
echo "====================================================================="
echo " Generated by BenchKit 2-4028"
echo " Executing tool itstools"
echo " Input is Sudoku-PT-AN04, examination is LTLFireability"
echo " Time confinement is $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT seconds"
echo " Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes"
echo " Number of cores is 4"
echo " Run identifier is r254-tall-162106746200581"
echo "====================================================================="
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "preparation of the directory to be used:"
tar xzf /home/mcc/BenchKit/INPUTS/Sudoku-PT-AN04.tgz
mv Sudoku-PT-AN04 execution
cd execution
if [ "LTLFireability" = "ReachabilityDeadlock" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "UpperBounds" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "QuasiLiveness" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "StableMarking" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "Liveness" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "OneSafe" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "StateSpace" ]; then
rm -f GenericPropertiesVerdict.xml
fi
pwd
ls -lh
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stdout:"
echo
echo "=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)"
echo
if [ "LTLFireability" = "UpperBounds" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of positive values"
echo NUM_VECTOR
elif [ "LTLFireability" != "StateSpace" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of booleans"
echo BOOL_VECTOR
else
echo "no data necessary for post analysis"
fi
echo
if [ -f "LTLFireability.txt" ] ; then
echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)"
for x in $(grep Property LTLFireability.txt | cut -d ' ' -f 2 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
elif [ -f "LTLFireability.xml" ] ; then # for cunf (txt files deleted;-)
echo echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from xml file)"
for x in $(grep '
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
elif [ "LTLFireability" = "ReachabilityDeadlock" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "QuasiLiveness" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "StableMarking" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "Liveness" ] || [ "LTLFireability" = "OneSafe" ] ; then
echo "FORMULA_NAME LTLFireability"
fi
echo
echo "=== Now, execution of the tool begins"
echo
echo -n "BK_START "
date -u +%s%3N
echo
timeout -s 9 $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT bash -c "/home/mcc/BenchKit/BenchKit_head.sh 2> STDERR ; echo ; echo -n \"BK_STOP \" ; date -u +%s%3N"
if [ $? -eq 137 ] ; then
echo
echo "BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT_REACHED"
fi
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stderr:"
echo
cat STDERR ;