Execution Chart

We display below the execution chart for this examination (boot time has been removed).

Trace from the execution

Waiting for the VM to be ready (probing ssh)
.......
=====================================================================
Generated by BenchKit 2-3254
Executing tool itstools
Input is SimpleLoadBal-COL-02, examination is CTLFireability
Time confinement is 3600 seconds
Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes
Number of cores is 4
Run identifier is r070-csrt-149440964900346
=====================================================================

--------------------
content from stdout:

=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)

The expected result is a vector of booleans
BOOL_VECTOR

here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-0
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-1
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-10
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-11
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-12
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-13
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-14
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-15
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-2
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-3
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-4
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-5
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-6
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-7
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-8
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-9

=== Now, execution of the tool begins

BK_START 1496321326523


its-ctl command run as :

/home/mcc/BenchKit/eclipse/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.itstools.binaries_1.0.0.201705302212/bin/its-ctl-linux64 --gc-threshold 2000000 --quiet -i /home/mcc/execution/CTLFireability.pnml.gal -t CGAL -ctl /home/mcc/execution/CTLFireability.ctl
No direction supplied, using forward translation only.
Parsed 16 CTL formulae.
Model ,|S| ,Time ,Mem(kb) ,fin. SDD ,fin. DDD ,peak SDD ,peak DDD ,SDD Hom ,SDD cache peak ,DDD Hom ,DDD cachepeak ,SHom cache
reachable,832,0.049923,6028,222,18,3013,155,131,1728,41,158,0


Converting to forward existential form...Done !
original formula: (((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [(Init * (((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)))] != FALSE
(forward)formula 0,0,0.054289,6040,1,0,3013,155,161,1728,43,158,32
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-0 FALSE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is FALSE !

***************************************

original formula: EG(AF(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [FwdG(Init,!(EG(!(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))))))] != FALSE
(forward)formula 1,0,0.099074,6844,1,0,5297,155,1088,4740,191,158,14439
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-1 FALSE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is FALSE !

***************************************

original formula: (EG((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + (((((client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1) + (client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) * ((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)))) * ((((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)) + (server_id0.P_server_processed_0>=1 + server_id1.P_server_processed_1>=1)) * ((((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) * ((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)))))) + E(!((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) * (((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)))) U (!(((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1))) * !(((client_id0.P_client_waiting_0>=1 * client_id0.P_client_ack_0>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_waiting_1>=1 * client_id1.P_client_ack_1>=1))))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: ([FwdG(Init,(((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + (((((client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1) + (client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) * ((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)))) * ((((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)) + (server_id0.P_server_processed_0>=1 + server_id1.P_server_processed_1>=1)) * ((((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) * ((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1))))))] != FALSE + [(FwdU(Init,!((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) * (((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1))))) * (!(((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1))) * !(((client_id0.P_client_waiting_0>=1 * client_id0.P_client_ack_0>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_waiting_1>=1 * client_id1.P_client_ack_1>=1)))))] != FALSE)
(forward)formula 2,1,0.123129,7792,1,0,7350,155,1254,6547,201,158,21626
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-2 TRUE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is TRUE !

***************************************

original formula: EG(EF((((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [FwdG(Init,E(TRUE U (((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1))))] != FALSE
(forward)formula 3,1,0.133253,8288,1,0,8331,155,1284,7713,207,158,24587
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-3 TRUE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is TRUE !

***************************************

original formula: AG((((((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1))) * (((((client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1) + (client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [(FwdU(Init,TRUE) * !((((((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1))) * (((((client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1) + (client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1))))))] = FALSE
(forward)formula 4,0,0.142884,8548,1,0,8381,155,1358,7791,207,158,25310
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-4 FALSE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is FALSE !

***************************************

original formula: !(E(EF(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))) U EG((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [FwdG(FwdU(Init,E(TRUE U ((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))),(((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)))] = FALSE
(forward)formula 5,1,0.15521,8660,1,0,9422,155,1376,8511,207,158,28743
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-5 TRUE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is TRUE !

***************************************

original formula: (EF(!((!(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))) + ((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1))))) * EF((EX((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1))) + (((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((((client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1) + (client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1))) + (((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) * (((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)))))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: ([(EY(FwdU((Init * E(TRUE U !((!(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))) + ((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)))))),TRUE)) * (((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)))] != FALSE + [(FwdU((Init * E(TRUE U !((!(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))) + ((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)))))),TRUE) * (((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((((client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1) + (client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1))) + (((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) * (((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)))))] != FALSE)
(forward)formula 6,1,0.15974,8820,1,0,9433,155,1390,8550,207,158,28993
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-6 TRUE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is TRUE !

***************************************

original formula: AX(((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [(EY(Init) * !(((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1))))] = FALSE
(forward)formula 7,0,0.16095,8916,1,0,9511,155,1390,8666,207,158,29306
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-7 FALSE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is FALSE !

***************************************

original formula: (AF((((((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1)) + ((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)))) + ((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [FwdG((Init * !(((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))),!((((((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1)) + ((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)))))] = FALSE
(forward)formula 8,1,0.177771,9728,1,0,12641,155,1435,10822,207,158,39103
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-8 TRUE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is TRUE !

***************************************

original formula: AG(EF(!((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) * (client_id0.P_client_idle_0>=1 + client_id1.P_client_idle_1>=1)))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [(FwdU(Init,TRUE) * !(E(TRUE U !((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) * (client_id0.P_client_idle_0>=1 + client_id1.P_client_idle_1>=1))))))] = FALSE
(forward)formula 9,1,0.183037,10124,1,0,12779,155,1441,10927,207,158,39386
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-9 TRUE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is TRUE !

***************************************

original formula: (AF((AF(((((client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1) + (client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1))) * AX((((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1))))) * (AF(!(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))))) + (((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)) + !(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: ([FwdG(Init,!((!(EG(!(((((client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1) + (client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_idle_0>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id1.P_server_request_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1)) + (client_id_x_server_id3.P_server_request_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_idle_1>=1))))) * !(EX(!((((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1))))))))] = FALSE * [FwdG((Init * !((((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)) + !(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))))),!(!(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))))))] = FALSE)
(forward)formula 10,0,0.3366,17060,1,0,32263,155,1483,29039,207,171,90392
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-10 FALSE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is FALSE !

***************************************

original formula: !(AG(E((client_id0.P_client_idle_0>=1 + client_id1.P_client_idle_1>=1) U (((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [(FwdU(Init,TRUE) * !(E((client_id0.P_client_idle_0>=1 + client_id1.P_client_idle_1>=1) U (((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)))))] != FALSE
(forward)formula 11,1,0.359465,18112,1,0,35710,155,1508,32152,207,172,97856
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-11 TRUE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is TRUE !

***************************************

original formula: EF((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) * A(((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)) U ((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [(((FwdU(Init,TRUE) * ((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))) * !(EG(!(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))))) * !(E(!(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1))) U (!(((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1))) * !(((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))))))] != FALSE
(forward)formula 12,0,0.374497,18428,1,0,35772,155,1514,32364,207,172,98211
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-12 FALSE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is FALSE !

***************************************

original formula: (AF(AX((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) * (client_id0.P_client_idle_0>=1 + client_id1.P_client_idle_1>=1)))) + (((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [FwdG((Init * !((((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1) * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)))),!(!(EX(!((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id0.P_server_request_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + (((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * client_id_x_server_id2.P_server_request_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) * (client_id0.P_client_idle_0>=1 + client_id1.P_client_idle_1>=1)))))))] = FALSE
(forward)formula 13,0,0.378669,18504,1,0,35920,155,1545,32565,207,172,98541
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-13 FALSE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is FALSE !

***************************************

original formula: A((EG((((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1))) + EG((server_id0.P_server_processed_0>=1 + server_id1.P_server_processed_1>=1))) U (!((((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) * ((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))) * !((((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)) + ((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1))))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: [((Init * !(EG(!((!((((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) * ((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))) * !((((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)) + ((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1))))))))) * !(E(!((!((((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) * ((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))) * !((((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)) + ((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)))))) U (!((EG((((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1))) + EG((server_id0.P_server_processed_0>=1 + server_id1.P_server_processed_1>=1)))) * !((!((((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)) * ((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1)))) * !((((server_id0.P_server_waiting_0>=1 * server_id0.P_server_notification_ack_0>=1) + (server_id1.P_server_waiting_1>=1 * server_id1.P_server_notification_ack_1>=1)) + ((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1))))))))))] != FALSE
(forward)formula 14,1,0.455131,20388,1,0,41196,155,1579,37886,207,178,111549
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-14 TRUE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is TRUE !

***************************************

original formula: (AX((!(((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1))) + AF((((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1))))) * E((((((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + (((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1))) + (client_id0.P_client_idle_0>=1 + client_id1.P_client_idle_1>=1)) U EX(((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1)))))
=> equivalent forward existential formula: ([FwdG((EY(Init) * !(!(((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1))))),!((((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1))))] = FALSE * [(Init * !(E((((((((((((((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id0.P_lb_routing_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1) * lb_id_x_client_id1.P_lb_routing_1>=1)) + (((((((server_id_x_clients_no0.P_lb_load_0>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1) + ((server_id_x_clients_no1.P_lb_load_1>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no2.P_lb_load_2>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id0.P_server_notification_0>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no3.P_lb_load_3>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no4.P_lb_load_4>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1)) + ((server_id_x_clients_no5.P_lb_load_5>=1 * P_lb_balancing.P_lb_balancing[0]>=1) * server_id1.P_server_notification_1>=1))) + (client_id0.P_client_idle_0>=1 + client_id1.P_client_idle_1>=1)) U EX(((client_id0.P_client_request_0>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1) + (client_id1.P_client_request_1>=1 * P_lb_idle.P_lb_idle[0]>=1))))))] = FALSE)
(forward)formula 15,1,0.494185,21928,1,0,44977,155,1598,41884,207,178,121443
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-02-CTLFireability-15 TRUE TECHNIQUES DECISION_DIAGRAMS TOPOLOGICAL USE_NUPN
Formula is TRUE !

***************************************

Exit code :0

BK_STOP 1496321330912

--------------------
content from stderr:

+ export BINDIR=/home/mcc/BenchKit/
+ BINDIR=/home/mcc/BenchKit/
++ pwd
+ export MODEL=/home/mcc/execution
+ MODEL=/home/mcc/execution
+ [[ CTLFireability = StateSpace ]]
+ /home/mcc/BenchKit//runeclipse.sh /home/mcc/execution CTLFireability -its -ltsminpath /home/mcc/BenchKit//lts_install_dir/ -smt
+ ulimit -s 65536
+ java -Dosgi.requiredJavaVersion=1.6 -Xss8m -Xms40m -Xmx8192m -Declipse.pde.launch=true -Dfile.encoding=UTF-8 -classpath /home/mcc/BenchKit//eclipse/plugins/org.eclipse.equinox.launcher_1.3.201.v20161025-1711.jar org.eclipse.equinox.launcher.Main -application fr.lip6.move.gal.application.pnmcc -data /home/mcc/BenchKit//workspace -os linux -ws gtk -arch x86_64 -nl en_US -consoleLog -pnfolder /home/mcc/execution -examination CTLFireability -yices2path /home/mcc/BenchKit//yices/bin/yices -its -ltsminpath /home/mcc/BenchKit//lts_install_dir/ -smt
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:48 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.application.MccTranslator transformPNML
INFO: Parsing pnml file : /home/mcc/execution/model.pnml
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:48 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.pnml.togal.PnmlToGalTransformer transform
INFO: Detected file is not PT type :http://www.pnml.org/version-2009/grammar/symmetricnet
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.pnml.togal.PnmlToGalTransformer transform
INFO: Load time of PNML (colored model parsed with PNMLFW) : 1369 ms
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.pnml.togal.HLGALTransformer handlePage
INFO: Transformed 14 places.
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.pnml.togal.HLGALTransformer handlePage
INFO: Computed order using colors.
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.pnml.togal.HLGALTransformer handlePage
INFO: sort/places :lb_id * client_id->P-lb_routing,
client_id * server_id->P-server_request,
lb_id->P-lb_idle,P-lb_balancing,
server_id * clients_no->P-lb_load,
server_id->P-server_idle,P-server_waiting,P-server_processed,P-server_notification,P-server_notification_ack,
client_id->P-client_idle,P-client_waiting,P-client_request,P-client_ack,

Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.pnml.togal.HLGALTransformer handlePage
INFO: Transformed 13 transitions.
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.pnml.togal.PnmlToGalTransformer transform
INFO: Computed order based on color domains.
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.application.MccTranslator applyOrder
INFO: Applying decomposition
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.instantiate.CompositeBuilder decomposeWithOrder
INFO: Decomposing Gal with order
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.instantiate.Instantiator instantiateParameters
INFO: On-the-fly reduction of False transitions avoided exploring 29 instantiations of transitions. Total transitions/syncs built is 65
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:49 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.instantiate.GALRewriter flatten
INFO: Flatten gal took : 61 ms
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:50 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.instantiate.CompositeBuilder rewriteArraysToAllowPartition
INFO: Rewriting arrays P_client_idle, P_client_waiting, P_client_request, P_client_ack, P_server_idle, P_server_waiting, P_server_processed, P_server_notification, P_server_notification_ack, P_server_request, P_lb_routing, P_lb_load to variables to allow decomposition.
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:50 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.instantiate.Instantiator fuseIsomorphicEffects
INFO: Removed a total of 145 redundant transitions.
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:50 PM fr.lip6.move.serialization.SerializationUtil systemToFile
INFO: Time to serialize gal into /home/mcc/execution/CTLFireability.pnml.gal : 11 ms
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:50 PM fr.lip6.move.serialization.SerializationUtil serializePropertiesForITSCTLTools
INFO: Time to serialize properties into /home/mcc/execution/CTLFireability.ctl : 6 ms
Jun 01, 2017 12:48:50 PM fr.lip6.move.gal.itstools.Runner runTool
INFO: Standard error output from running tool CommandLine [args=[/home/mcc/BenchKit/eclipse/plugins/fr.lip6.move.gal.itstools.binaries_1.0.0.201705302212/bin/its-ctl-linux64, --gc-threshold, 2000000, --quiet, -i, /home/mcc/execution/CTLFireability.pnml.gal, -t, CGAL, -ctl, /home/mcc/execution/CTLFireability.ctl], workingDir=/home/mcc/execution]
built 42 ordering constraints for composite.
Reverse transition relation is NOT exact ! Due to transitions T_server_process_0, T_server_process_1, T_lb_idle_receive_notification, T_lb_no_balance_1_0_2, T_lb_balance_to_1_2_0_0_0, T_lb_balance_to_1_2_0_0_1, T_lb_balancing_receive_notification, Intersection with reachable at each step enabled. (destroyed/reverse/intersect/total) :3/29/7/39

Sequence of Actions to be Executed by the VM

This is useful if one wants to reexecute the tool in the VM from the submitted image disk.

set -x
# this is for BenchKit: configuration of major elements for the test
export BK_INPUT="SimpleLoadBal-COL-02"
export BK_EXAMINATION="CTLFireability"
export BK_TOOL="itstools"
export BK_RESULT_DIR="/tmp/BK_RESULTS/OUTPUTS"
export BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT="3600"
export BK_MEMORY_CONFINEMENT="16384"

# this is specific to your benchmark or test

export BIN_DIR="$HOME/BenchKit/bin"

# remove the execution directoty if it exists (to avoid increse of .vmdk images)
if [ -d execution ] ; then
rm -rf execution
fi

tar xzf /home/mcc/BenchKit/INPUTS/SimpleLoadBal-COL-02.tgz
mv SimpleLoadBal-COL-02 execution

# this is for BenchKit: explicit launching of the test

cd execution
echo "====================================================================="
echo " Generated by BenchKit 2-3254"
echo " Executing tool itstools"
echo " Input is SimpleLoadBal-COL-02, examination is CTLFireability"
echo " Time confinement is $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT seconds"
echo " Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes"
echo " Number of cores is 4"
echo " Run identifier is r070-csrt-149440964900346"
echo "====================================================================="
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stdout:"
echo
echo "=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)"
echo
if [ "CTLFireability" = "UpperBounds" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of positive values"
echo NUM_VECTOR
elif [ "CTLFireability" != "StateSpace" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of booleans"
echo BOOL_VECTOR
else
echo "no data necessary for post analysis"
fi
echo
if [ -f "CTLFireability.txt" ] ; then
echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)"
for x in $(grep Property CTLFireability.txt | cut -d ' ' -f 2 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
elif [ -f "CTLFireability.xml" ] ; then # for cunf (txt files deleted;-)
echo echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from xml file)"
for x in $(grep '' CTLFireability.xml | cut -d '>' -f 2 | cut -d '<' -f 1 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
fi
echo
echo "=== Now, execution of the tool begins"
echo
echo -n "BK_START "
date -u +%s%3N
echo
timeout -s 9 $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT bash -c "/home/mcc/BenchKit/BenchKit_head.sh 2> STDERR ; echo ; echo -n \"BK_STOP \" ; date -u +%s%3N"
if [ $? -eq 137 ] ; then
echo
echo "BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT_REACHED"
fi
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stderr:"
echo
cat STDERR ;