Execution Chart

We display below the execution chart for this examination (boot time has been removed).

Trace from the execution

Waiting for the VM to be ready (probing ssh)
.......
=====================================================================
Generated by BenchKit 2-3254
Executing tool tapaal
Input is SimpleLoadBal-PT-15, examination is CTLCardinality
Time confinement is 3600 seconds
Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes
Number of cores is 4
Run identifier is r069-csrt-149440964100381
=====================================================================

--------------------
content from stdout:

=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)

The expected result is a vector of booleans
BOOL_VECTOR

here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-0
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-1
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-10
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-11
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-12
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-13
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-14
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-15
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-2
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-3
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-4
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-5
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-6
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-7
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-8
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-9

=== Now, execution of the tool begins

BK_START 1494839287670

---> tapaal --- TAPAAL
Total timeout: 3600

*************************************
* TAPAAL verifying CTLCardinality *
*************************************
---------------------------------------------------
Step 1: Parallel processing
---------------------------------------------------
Doing parallel verification of individual queries (16 in total)
Each query is verified by 2 parallel strategies for 60 seconds
------------------- QUERY 1 ----------------------
No solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 1

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 1


------------------- QUERY 2 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 2

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 2

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=ENABLED,QSTimeout=30,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10

Query before reduction: (EF ((not (1 <= (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_load_2_12) + P-lb_load_2_13) + P-lb_load_2_14) + P-lb_load_2_15))) and ((3 <= (P-server_notification_ack_1 + P-server_notification_ack_2)) and (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= P-lb_idle_1))) or (AX ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-server_request_1_1 + P-server_request_1_2) + P-server_request_2_1) + P-server_request_2_2) + P-server_request_3_1) + P-server_request_3_2) + P-server_request_4_1) + P-server_request_4_2) + P-server_request_5_1) + P-server_request_5_2) + P-server_request_6_1) + P-server_request_6_2) + P-server_request_7_1) + P-server_request_7_2) + P-server_request_8_1) + P-server_request_8_2) + P-server_request_9_1) + P-server_request_9_2) + P-server_request_10_1) + P-server_request_10_2) + P-server_request_11_1) + P-server_request_11_2) + P-server_request_12_1) + P-server_request_12_2) + P-server_request_13_1) + P-server_request_13_2) + P-server_request_14_1) + P-server_request_14_2) + P-server_request_15_1) + P-server_request_15_2) <= (P-server_processed_1 + P-server_processed_2)) and (1 <= P-lb_balancing_1)))
Query after reduction: (AX ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-server_request_1_1 + P-server_request_1_2) + P-server_request_2_1) + P-server_request_2_2) + P-server_request_3_1) + P-server_request_3_2) + P-server_request_4_1) + P-server_request_4_2) + P-server_request_5_1) + P-server_request_5_2) + P-server_request_6_1) + P-server_request_6_2) + P-server_request_7_1) + P-server_request_7_2) + P-server_request_8_1) + P-server_request_8_2) + P-server_request_9_1) + P-server_request_9_2) + P-server_request_10_1) + P-server_request_10_2) + P-server_request_11_1) + P-server_request_11_2) + P-server_request_12_1) + P-server_request_12_2) + P-server_request_13_1) + P-server_request_13_2) + P-server_request_14_1) + P-server_request_14_2) + P-server_request_15_1) + P-server_request_15_2) <= (P-server_processed_1 + P-server_processed_2)) and (1 <= P-lb_balancing_1))
Query size reduced from 173 to 68 nodes (60.69 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.033059 seconds.


Query is NOT satisfied.

STATS:
Time (seconds): 2e-06
Configurations: 1
Markings: 1
Edges: 0
Processed Edges: 0
Processed N. Edges: 0
Explored Configs: 1
Query: (AXtokens-count(P-server_request_1_1, P-server_request_1_2, P-server_request_2_1, P-server_request_2_2, P-server_request_3_1, P-server_request_3_2, P-server_request_4_1, P-server_request_4_2, P-server_request_5_1, P-server_request_5_2, P-server_request_6_1, P-server_request_6_2, P-server_request_7_1, P-server_request_7_2, P-server_request_8_1, P-server_request_8_2, P-server_request_9_1, P-server_request_9_2, P-server_request_10_1, P-server_request_10_2, P-server_request_11_1, P-server_request_11_2, P-server_request_12_1, P-server_request_12_2, P-server_request_13_1, P-server_request_13_2, P-server_request_14_1, P-server_request_14_2, P-server_request_15_1, P-server_request_15_2) le tokens-count(P-server_processed_1, P-server_processed_2) & integer-constant(1) le tokens-count(P-lb_balancing_1))

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 7250000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 2

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-1 FALSE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
------------------- QUERY 3 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 3

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 3

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=DISABLED,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10
Size of net before structural reductions: 149 places, 1280 transitions
Size of net after structural reductions: 134 places, 1265 transitions
Structural reduction finished after 0.009737 seconds

Net reduction is enabled.
Removed transitions: 15
Removed places: 15
Applications of rule A: 0
Applications of rule B: 15
Applications of rule C: 0
Applications of rule D: 0
Applications of rule E: 0

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=ENABLED,QSTimeout=30,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10

Query before reduction: EF (2 <= (P-server_notification_ack_1 + P-server_notification_ack_2))
Query after reduction: EF (2 <= (P-server_notification_ack_1 + P-server_notification_ack_2))
Query size reduced from 6 to 6 nodes (0.00 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.018502 seconds.
Size of net before structural reductions: 149 places, 1280 transitions
Size of net after structural reductions: 134 places, 1265 transitions
Structural reduction finished after 0.009399 seconds

Net reduction is enabled.
Removed transitions: 15
Removed places: 15
Applications of rule A: 0
Applications of rule B: 15
Applications of rule C: 0
Applications of rule D: 0
Applications of rule E: 0


Query is satisfied.

STATS:
discovered states: 2374
explored states: 2251
expanded states: 165
max tokens: 37



Query is satisfied.

STATS:
discovered states: 2374
explored states: 2251
expanded states: 165
max tokens: 37

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 14500000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -q\ 0\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 3

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-2 TRUE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
------------------- QUERY 4 ----------------------
No solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 4

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 4


------------------- QUERY 5 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 5

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 5

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=DISABLED,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10


Query is satisfied.

STATS:
Time (seconds): 0.000463
Configurations: 156
Markings: 140
Edges: 25
Processed Edges: 11
Processed N. Edges: 2
Explored Configs: 11
Query: EX!(AF!(!(tokens-count(P-client_idle_1, P-client_idle_2, P-client_idle_3, P-client_idle_4, P-client_idle_5, P-client_idle_6, P-client_idle_7, P-client_idle_8, P-client_idle_9, P-client_idle_10, P-client_idle_11, P-client_idle_12, P-client_idle_13, P-client_idle_14, P-client_idle_15) le tokens-count(P-server_waiting_1, P-server_waiting_2))))

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 14500000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -q\ 0\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 5

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-4 TRUE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
------------------- QUERY 6 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 6

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 6

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=DISABLED,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10


Query is satisfied.

STATS:
Time (seconds): 0.000223
Configurations: 79
Markings: 77
Edges: 79
Processed Edges: 15
Processed N. Edges: 0
Explored Configs: 8
Query: (EF!(tokens-count(P-server_waiting_1, P-server_waiting_2) le tokens-count(P-server_notification_ack_1, P-server_notification_ack_2)) | A((tokens-count(P-lb_load_1_0, P-lb_load_1_1, P-lb_load_1_2, P-lb_load_1_3, P-lb_load_1_4, P-lb_load_1_5, P-lb_load_1_6, P-lb_load_1_7, P-lb_load_1_8, P-lb_load_1_9, P-lb_load_1_10, P-lb_load_1_11, P-lb_load_1_12, P-lb_load_1_13, P-lb_load_1_14, P-lb_load_1_15, P-lb_load_2_0, P-lb_load_2_1, P-lb_load_2_2, P-lb_load_2_3, P-lb_load_2_4, P-lb_load_2_5, P-lb_load_2_6, P-lb_load_2_7, P-lb_load_2_8, P-lb_load_2_9, P-lb_load_2_10, P-lb_load_2_11, P-lb_load_2_12, P-lb_load_2_13, P-lb_load_2_14, P-lb_load_2_15) le tokens-count(P-lb_idle_1) & integer-constant(1) le tokens-count(P-lb_routing_1_1, P-lb_routing_1_2, P-lb_routing_1_3, P-lb_routing_1_4, P-lb_routing_1_5, P-lb_routing_1_6, P-lb_routing_1_7, P-lb_routing_1_8, P-lb_routing_1_9, P-lb_routing_1_10, P-lb_routing_1_11, P-lb_routing_1_12, P-lb_routing_1_13, P-lb_routing_1_14, P-lb_routing_1_15))) U (!(tokens-count(P-client_ack_1, P-client_ack_2, P-client_ack_3, P-client_ack_4, P-client_ack_5, P-client_ack_6, P-client_ack_7, P-client_ack_8, P-client_ack_9, P-client_ack_10, P-client_ack_11, P-client_ack_12, P-client_ack_13, P-client_ack_14, P-client_ack_15) le tokens-count(P-server_request_1_1, P-server_request_1_2, P-server_request_2_1, P-server_request_2_2, P-server_request_3_1, P-server_request_3_2, P-server_request_4_1, P-server_request_4_2, P-server_request_5_1, P-server_request_5_2, P-server_request_6_1, P-server_request_6_2, P-server_request_7_1, P-server_request_7_2, P-server_request_8_1, P-server_request_8_2, P-server_request_9_1, P-server_request_9_2, P-server_request_10_1, P-server_request_10_2, P-server_request_11_1, P-server_request_11_2, P-server_request_12_1, P-server_request_12_2, P-server_request_13_1, P-server_request_13_2, P-server_request_14_1, P-server_request_14_2, P-server_request_15_1, P-server_request_15_2))))

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 14500000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -q\ 0\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 6

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-5 TRUE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
------------------- QUERY 7 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 7

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 7

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=DISABLED,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10


Query is NOT satisfied.

STATS:
Time (seconds): 0.004824
Configurations: 1716
Markings: 1715
Edges: 136
Processed Edges: 136
Processed N. Edges: 0
Explored Configs: 122
Query: EXAF(integer-constant(2) le tokens-count(P-server_waiting_1, P-server_waiting_2) | integer-constant(2) le tokens-count(P-client_waiting_1, P-client_waiting_2, P-client_waiting_3, P-client_waiting_4, P-client_waiting_5, P-client_waiting_6, P-client_waiting_7, P-client_waiting_8, P-client_waiting_9, P-client_waiting_10, P-client_waiting_11, P-client_waiting_12, P-client_waiting_13, P-client_waiting_14, P-client_waiting_15))

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 14500000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -q\ 0\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 7

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-6 FALSE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
------------------- QUERY 8 ----------------------
No solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 8

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 8


------------------- QUERY 9 ----------------------
No solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 9

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 9

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=ENABLED,QSTimeout=30,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10

Query before reduction: (EG (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= (P-server_waiting_1 + P-server_waiting_2)) or (((not ((P-lb_idle_1 <= ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15)) and (((((((((((((((P-client_request_1 + P-client_request_2) + P-client_request_3) + P-client_request_4) + P-client_request_5) + P-client_request_6) + P-client_request_7) + P-client_request_8) + P-client_request_9) + P-client_request_10) + P-client_request_11) + P-client_request_12) + P-client_request_13) + P-client_request_14) + P-client_request_15) <= (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_load_2_12) + P-lb_load_2_13) + P-lb_load_2_14) + P-lb_load_2_15)))) and (not (not (1 <= ((((((((((((((P-client_idle_1 + P-client_idle_2) + P-client_idle_3) + P-client_idle_4) + P-client_idle_5) + P-client_idle_6) + P-client_idle_7) + P-client_idle_8) + P-client_idle_9) + P-client_idle_10) + P-client_idle_11) + P-client_idle_12) + P-client_idle_13) + P-client_idle_14) + P-client_idle_15))))) and AG (not (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= P-lb_balancing_1))))
Query after reduction: (EG (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= (P-server_waiting_1 + P-server_waiting_2)) or ((((P-lb_idle_1 > ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15)) or (((((((((((((((P-client_request_1 + P-client_request_2) + P-client_request_3) + P-client_request_4) + P-client_request_5) + P-client_request_6) + P-client_request_7) + P-client_request_8) + P-client_request_9) + P-client_request_10) + P-client_request_11) + P-client_request_12) + P-client_request_13) + P-client_request_14) + P-client_request_15) > (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_loa


------------------- QUERY 10 ----------------------
No solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 10

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 10


------------------- QUERY 11 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 11

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 11

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=DISABLED,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10


Query is NOT satisfied.

STATS:
Time (seconds): 0.000532
Configurations: 168
Markings: 151
Edges: 47
Processed Edges: 94
Processed N. Edges: 0
Explored Configs: 48
Query: A(EXinteger-constant(1) le tokens-count(P-client_idle_1, P-client_idle_2, P-client_idle_3, P-client_idle_4, P-client_idle_5, P-client_idle_6, P-client_idle_7, P-client_idle_8, P-client_idle_9, P-client_idle_10, P-client_idle_11, P-client_idle_12, P-client_idle_13, P-client_idle_14, P-client_idle_15)) U ((!(tokens-count(P-server_request_1_1, P-server_request_1_2, P-server_request_2_1, P-server_request_2_2, P-server_request_3_1, P-server_request_3_2, P-server_request_4_1, P-server_request_4_2, P-server_request_5_1, P-server_request_5_2, P-server_request_6_1, P-server_request_6_2, P-server_request_7_1, P-server_request_7_2, P-server_request_8_1, P-server_request_8_2, P-server_request_9_1, P-server_request_9_2, P-server_request_10_1, P-server_request_10_2, P-server_request_11_1, P-server_request_11_2, P-server_request_12_1, P-server_request_12_2, P-server_request_13_1, P-server_request_13_2, P-server_request_14_1, P-server_request_14_2, P-server_request_15_1, P-server_request_15_2) le tokens-count(P-server_notification_1, P-server_notification_2)) | (integer-constant(3) le tokens-count(P-server_waiting_1, P-server_waiting_2) | integer-constant(3) le tokens-count(P-server_notification_1, P-server_notification_2))))

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 14500000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -q\ 0\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 11

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-10 FALSE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
------------------- QUERY 12 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 12

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 12

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=DISABLED,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10


Query is NOT satisfied.

STATS:
Time (seconds): 0.000208
Configurations: 77
Markings: 77
Edges: 5
Processed Edges: 10
Processed N. Edges: 0
Explored Configs: 6
Query: A((!(tokens-count(P-lb_balancing_1) le tokens-count(P-client_waiting_1, P-client_waiting_2, P-client_waiting_3, P-client_waiting_4, P-client_waiting_5, P-client_waiting_6, P-client_waiting_7, P-client_waiting_8, P-client_waiting_9, P-client_waiting_10, P-client_waiting_11, P-client_waiting_12, P-client_waiting_13, P-client_waiting_14, P-client_waiting_15)) | (integer-constant(1) le tokens-count(P-server_idle_1, P-server_idle_2) & tokens-count(P-client_ack_1, P-client_ack_2, P-client_ack_3, P-client_ack_4, P-client_ack_5, P-client_ack_6, P-client_ack_7, P-client_ack_8, P-client_ack_9, P-client_ack_10, P-client_ack_11, P-client_ack_12, P-client_ack_13, P-client_ack_14, P-client_ack_15) le tokens-count(P-server_processed_1, P-server_processed_2)))) U (!((integer-constant(2) le tokens-count(P-client_idle_1, P-client_idle_2, P-client_idle_3, P-client_idle_4, P-client_idle_5, P-client_idle_6, P-client_idle_7, P-client_idle_8, P-client_idle_9, P-client_idle_10, P-client_idle_11, P-client_idle_12, P-client_idle_13, P-client_idle_14, P-client_idle_15) | tokens-count(P-lb_balancing_1) le tokens-count(P-client_request_1, P-client_request_2, P-client_request_3, P-client_request_4, P-client_request_5, P-client_request_6, P-client_request_7, P-client_request_8, P-client_request_9, P-client_request_10, P-client_request_11, P-client_request_12, P-client_request_13, P-client_request_14, P-client_request_15))))

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 14500000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -q\ 0\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 12

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-11 FALSE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
------------------- QUERY 13 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 13

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 13

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=DISABLED,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10


Query is NOT satisfied.

STATS:
Time (seconds): 0.000487
Configurations: 160
Markings: 140
Edges: 38
Processed Edges: 39
Processed N. Edges: 27
Explored Configs: 29
Query: ((tokens-count(P-lb_load_1_0, P-lb_load_1_1, P-lb_load_1_2, P-lb_load_1_3, P-lb_load_1_4, P-lb_load_1_5, P-lb_load_1_6, P-lb_load_1_7, P-lb_load_1_8, P-lb_load_1_9, P-lb_load_1_10, P-lb_load_1_11, P-lb_load_1_12, P-lb_load_1_13, P-lb_load_1_14, P-lb_load_1_15, P-lb_load_2_0, P-lb_load_2_1, P-lb_load_2_2, P-lb_load_2_3, P-lb_load_2_4, P-lb_load_2_5, P-lb_load_2_6, P-lb_load_2_7, P-lb_load_2_8, P-lb_load_2_9, P-lb_load_2_10, P-lb_load_2_11, P-lb_load_2_12, P-lb_load_2_13, P-lb_load_2_14, P-lb_load_2_15) le tokens-count(P-client_request_1, P-client_request_2, P-client_request_3, P-client_request_4, P-client_request_5, P-client_request_6, P-client_request_7, P-client_request_8, P-client_request_9, P-client_request_10, P-client_request_11, P-client_request_12, P-client_request_13, P-client_request_14, P-client_request_15) & EFinteger-constant(2) le tokens-count(P-lb_idle_1)) | AF!(AF!(integer-constant(3) le tokens-count(P-client_request_1, P-client_request_2, P-client_request_3, P-client_request_4, P-client_request_5, P-client_request_6, P-client_request_7, P-client_request_8, P-client_request_9, P-client_request_10, P-client_request_11, P-client_request_12, P-client_request_13, P-client_request_14, P-client_request_15))))

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 14500000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -q\ 0\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 13

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-12 FALSE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
------------------- QUERY 14 ----------------------
No solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 14

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 14


------------------- QUERY 15 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 15

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 15

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=DISABLED,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10


Query is NOT satisfied.

STATS:
Time (seconds): 0.000251
Configurations: 96
Markings: 77
Edges: 96
Processed Edges: 19
Processed N. Edges: 2
Explored Configs: 11
Query: (!((EFinteger-constant(1) le tokens-count(P-server_waiting_1, P-server_waiting_2) | ((integer-constant(3) le tokens-count(P-lb_routing_1_1, P-lb_routing_1_2, P-lb_routing_1_3, P-lb_routing_1_4, P-lb_routing_1_5, P-lb_routing_1_6, P-lb_routing_1_7, P-lb_routing_1_8, P-lb_routing_1_9, P-lb_routing_1_10, P-lb_routing_1_11, P-lb_routing_1_12, P-lb_routing_1_13, P-lb_routing_1_14, P-lb_routing_1_15) & tokens-count(P-server_waiting_1, P-server_waiting_2) le tokens-count(P-server_processed_1, P-server_processed_2)) & !(tokens-count(P-client_idle_1, P-client_idle_2, P-client_idle_3, P-client_idle_4, P-client_idle_5, P-client_idle_6, P-client_idle_7, P-client_idle_8, P-client_idle_9, P-client_idle_10, P-client_idle_11, P-client_idle_12, P-client_idle_13, P-client_idle_14, P-client_idle_15) le tokens-count(P-server_notification_ack_1, P-server_notification_ack_2))))) & EXEFtokens-count(P-client_ack_1, P-client_ack_2, P-client_ack_3, P-client_ack_4, P-client_ack_5, P-client_ack_6, P-client_ack_7, P-client_ack_8, P-client_ack_9, P-client_ack_10, P-client_ack_11, P-client_ack_12, P-client_ack_13, P-client_ack_14, P-client_ack_15) le tokens-count(P-lb_load_1_0, P-lb_load_1_1, P-lb_load_1_2, P-lb_load_1_3, P-lb_load_1_4, P-lb_load_1_5, P-lb_load_1_6, P-lb_load_1_7, P-lb_load_1_8, P-lb_load_1_9, P-lb_load_1_10, P-lb_load_1_11, P-lb_load_1_12, P-lb_load_1_13, P-lb_load_1_14, P-lb_load_1_15, P-lb_load_2_0, P-lb_load_2_1, P-lb_load_2_2, P-lb_load_2_3, P-lb_load_2_4, P-lb_load_2_5, P-lb_load_2_6, P-lb_load_2_7, P-lb_load_2_8, P-lb_load_2_9, P-lb_load_2_10, P-lb_load_2_11, P-lb_load_2_12, P-lb_load_2_13, P-lb_load_2_14, P-lb_load_2_15))

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 14500000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -q\ 0\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 15

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-14 FALSE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
------------------- QUERY 16 ----------------------
Solution found
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").
perl: warning: Setting locale failed.
perl: warning: Please check that your locale settings:
LANGUAGE = (unset),
LC_ALL = (unset),
LANG = "en_US.UTF-8"
are supported and installed on your system.
perl: warning: Falling back to the standard locale ("C").

Parameters: -s DFS -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 16

Parameters: -s DFS -q 0 -d 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 16

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=10,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=ENABLED,QSTimeout=30,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10

Query before reduction: AG (1 <= (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_load_2_12) + P-lb_load_2_13) + P-lb_load_2_14) + P-lb_load_2_15))
Query after reduction: true
Query size reduced from 66 to 1 nodes (98.48 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.000941 seconds.


Query is satisfied.

Query solved by Query Simplification.

parallel: This job succeeded:
/home/mcc/BenchKit/start.sh 7250000 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s\ DFS\ -d\ 10 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 16

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-CTLCardinality-15 TRUE TECHNIQUES COLLATERAL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION STATE_COMPRESSION STUBBORN_SETS
---------------------------------------------------
Step 2: Sequential processing
---------------------------------------------------
Remaining queries are verified sequentially.
Each query is verified for a dynamic timeout (at least 480 seconds)
------------------- QUERY 1 ----------------------
Running query 1 for 539 seconds. Remaining: 6 queries and 3222 seconds

Parameters: -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 1

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=100,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=ENABLED,QSTimeout=100,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10

Query before reduction: A ((1 <= (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_load_2_12) + P-lb_load_2_13) + P-lb_load_2_14) + P-lb_load_2_15)) U AG ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-server_request_1_1 + P-server_request_1_2) + P-server_request_2_1) + P-server_request_2_2) + P-server_request_3_1) + P-server_request_3_2) + P-server_request_4_1) + P-server_request_4_2) + P-server_request_5_1) + P-server_request_5_2) + P-server_request_6_1) + P-server_request_6_2) + P-server_request_7_1) + P-server_request_7_2) + P-server_request_8_1) + P-server_request_8_2) + P-server_request_9_1) + P-server_request_9_2) + P-server_request_10_1) + P-server_request_10_2) + P-server_request_11_1) + P-server_request_11_2) + P-server_request_12_1) + P-server_request_12_2) + P-server_request_13_1) + P-server_request_13_2) + P-server_request_14_1) + P-server_request_14_2) + P-server_request_15_1) + P-server_request_15_2) <= ((((((((((((((P-client_idle_1 + P-client_idle_2) + P-client_idle_3) + P-client_idle_4) + P-client_idle_5) + P-client_idle_6) + P-client_idle_7) + P-client_idle_8) + P-client_idle_9) + P-client_idle_10) + P-client_idle_11) + P-client_idle_12) + P-client_idle_13) + P-client_idle_14) + P-client_idle_15)))
Query after reduction: AF AG ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-server_request_1_1 + P-server_request_1_2) + P-server_request_2_1) + P-server_request_2_2) + P-server_request_3_1) + P-server_request_3_2) + P-server_request_4_1) + P-server_request_4_2) + P-server_request_5_1) + P-server_request_5_2) + P-server_request_6_1) + P-server_request_6_2) + P-server_request_7_1) + P-server_request_7_2) + P-server_request_8_1) + P-server_request_8_2) + P-server_request_9_1) + P-server_request_9_2) + P-server_request_10_1) + P-server_request_10_2) + P-server_request_11_1) + P-server_request_11_2) + P-server_request_12_1) + P-server_request_12_2) + P-server_request_13_1) + P-server_request_13_2) + P-server_request_14_1) + P-server_request_14_2) + P-server_request_15_1) + P-server_request_15_2) <= ((((((((((((((P-client_idle_1 + P-client_idle_2) + P-client_idle_3) + P-client_idle_4) + P-client_idle_5) + P-client_idle_6) + P-client_idle_7) + P-client_idle_8) + P-client_idle_9) + P-client_idle_10) + P-client_idle_11) + P-client_idle_12) + P-client_idle_13) + P-client_idle_14) + P-client_idle_15))
Query size reduced from 156 to 91 nodes (41.67 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.015720 seconds.
No solution found
------------------- QUERY 4 ----------------------
Running query 4 for 617 seconds. Remaining: 5 queries and 3075 seconds

Parameters: -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 4

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=100,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=ENABLED,QSTimeout=100,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10

Query before reduction: (not AG EG ((P-server_notification_ack_1 + P-server_notification_ack_2) <= ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15)))
Query after reduction: EF AF ((P-server_notification_ack_1 + P-server_notification_ack_2) > ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15))
Query size reduced from 35 to 35 nodes (0.00 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.017936 seconds.
No solution found
------------------- QUERY 8 ----------------------
Running query 8 for 689 seconds. Remaining: 4 queries and 2750 seconds

Parameters: -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 8
No solution found
------------------- QUERY 9 ----------------------
Running query 9 for 863 seconds. Remaining: 3 queries and 2584 seconds

Parameters: -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 9

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=100,Stubborn_Reduction=ENABLED,Query_Simplication=ENABLED,QSTimeout=100,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10

Query before reduction: (EG (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= (P-server_waiting_1 + P-server_waiting_2)) or (((not ((P-lb_idle_1 <= ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15)) and (((((((((((((((P-client_request_1 + P-client_request_2) + P-client_request_3) + P-client_request_4) + P-client_request_5) + P-client_request_6) + P-client_request_7) + P-client_request_8) + P-client_request_9) + P-client_request_10) + P-client_request_11) + P-client_request_12) + P-client_request_13) + P-client_request_14) + P-client_request_15) <= (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_load_2_12) + P-lb_load_2_13) + P-lb_load_2_14) + P-lb_load_2_15)))) and (not (not (1 <= ((((((((((((((P-client_idle_1 + P-client_idle_2) + P-client_idle_3) + P-client_idle_4) + P-client_idle_5) + P-client_idle_6) + P-client_idle_7) + P-client_idle_8) + P-client_idle_9) + P-client_idle_10) + P-client_idle_11) + P-client_idle_12) + P-client_idle_13) + P-client_idle_14) + P-client_idle_15))))) and AG (not (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= P-lb_balancing_1))))
Query after reduction: (EG (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= (P-server_waiting_1 + P-server_waiting_2)) or ((((P-lb_idle_1 > ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15)) or (((((((((((((((P-client_request_1 + P-client_request_2) + P-client_request_3) + P-client_request_4) + P-client_request_5) + P-client_request_6) + P-client_request_7) + P-client_request_8) + P-client_request_9) + P-client_request_10) + P-client_request_11) + P-client_request_12) + P-client_request_13) + P-client_request_14) + P-client_request_15) > (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_lNo solution found
------------------- QUERY 10 ----------------------
Running query 10 for 1210 seconds. Remaining: 2 queries and 2417 seconds

Parameters: -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 10
No solution found
------------------- QUERY 14 ----------------------
Running query 14 for 2274 seconds. Remaining: 1 queries and 2272 seconds

Parameters: -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 14
No solution found
---------------------------------------------------
Step 3: Multiquery processing
---------------------------------------------------
Remaining 6 queries are solved using multiquery
Time remaining: 2119 seconds of the initial 3600 seconds
Running multiquery on -x 1,4,8,9,10,14 for 2119 seconds

Parameters: -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 -p ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 1,4,8,9,10,14

Search=DFS,Trace=DISABLED,State_Space_Exploration=DISABLED,Structural_Reduction=AGGRESSIVE,Struct_Red_Timout=100,Stubborn_Reduction=DISABLED,Query_Simplication=ENABLED,QSTimeout=100,Siphon_Trap=DISABLED,LPSolve_Timeout=10

Query before reduction: A ((1 <= (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_load_2_12) + P-lb_load_2_13) + P-lb_load_2_14) + P-lb_load_2_15)) U AG ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-server_request_1_1 + P-server_request_1_2) + P-server_request_2_1) + P-server_request_2_2) + P-server_request_3_1) + P-server_request_3_2) + P-server_request_4_1) + P-server_request_4_2) + P-server_request_5_1) + P-server_request_5_2) + P-server_request_6_1) + P-server_request_6_2) + P-server_request_7_1) + P-server_request_7_2) + P-server_request_8_1) + P-server_request_8_2) + P-server_request_9_1) + P-server_request_9_2) + P-server_request_10_1) + P-server_request_10_2) + P-server_request_11_1) + P-server_request_11_2) + P-server_request_12_1) + P-server_request_12_2) + P-server_request_13_1) + P-server_request_13_2) + P-server_request_14_1) + P-server_request_14_2) + P-server_request_15_1) + P-server_request_15_2) <= ((((((((((((((P-client_idle_1 + P-client_idle_2) + P-client_idle_3) + P-client_idle_4) + P-client_idle_5) + P-client_idle_6) + P-client_idle_7) + P-client_idle_8) + P-client_idle_9) + P-client_idle_10) + P-client_idle_11) + P-client_idle_12) + P-client_idle_13) + P-client_idle_14) + P-client_idle_15)))
Query after reduction: AF AG ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-server_request_1_1 + P-server_request_1_2) + P-server_request_2_1) + P-server_request_2_2) + P-server_request_3_1) + P-server_request_3_2) + P-server_request_4_1) + P-server_request_4_2) + P-server_request_5_1) + P-server_request_5_2) + P-server_request_6_1) + P-server_request_6_2) + P-server_request_7_1) + P-server_request_7_2) + P-server_request_8_1) + P-server_request_8_2) + P-server_request_9_1) + P-server_request_9_2) + P-server_request_10_1) + P-server_request_10_2) + P-server_request_11_1) + P-server_request_11_2) + P-server_request_12_1) + P-server_request_12_2) + P-server_request_13_1) + P-server_request_13_2) + P-server_request_14_1) + P-server_request_14_2) + P-server_request_15_1) + P-server_request_15_2) <= ((((((((((((((P-client_idle_1 + P-client_idle_2) + P-client_idle_3) + P-client_idle_4) + P-client_idle_5) + P-client_idle_6) + P-client_idle_7) + P-client_idle_8) + P-client_idle_9) + P-client_idle_10) + P-client_idle_11) + P-client_idle_12) + P-client_idle_13) + P-client_idle_14) + P-client_idle_15))
Query size reduced from 156 to 91 nodes (41.67 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.016713 seconds.

Query before reduction: (not AG EG ((P-server_notification_ack_1 + P-server_notification_ack_2) <= ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15)))
Query after reduction: EF AF ((P-server_notification_ack_1 + P-server_notification_ack_2) > ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15))
Query size reduced from 35 to 35 nodes (0.00 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.016878 seconds.

Query before reduction: (not (AX ((1 <= P-lb_idle_1) or ((P-server_waiting_1 + P-server_waiting_2) <= (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-server_request_1_1 + P-server_request_1_2) + P-server_request_2_1) + P-server_request_2_2) + P-server_request_3_1) + P-server_request_3_2) + P-server_request_4_1) + P-server_request_4_2) + P-server_request_5_1) + P-server_request_5_2) + P-server_request_6_1) + P-server_request_6_2) + P-server_request_7_1) + P-server_request_7_2) + P-server_request_8_1) + P-server_request_8_2) + P-server_request_9_1) + P-server_request_9_2) + P-server_request_10_1) + P-server_request_10_2) + P-server_request_11_1) + P-server_request_11_2) + P-server_request_12_1) + P-server_request_12_2) + P-server_request_13_1) + P-server_request_13_2) + P-server_request_14_1) + P-server_request_14_2) + P-server_request_15_1) + P-server_request_15_2))) and AF (1 <= ((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15))))
Query after reduction: (EX ((1 > P-lb_idle_1) and ((P-server_waiting_1 + P-server_waiting_2) > (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-server_request_1_1 + P-server_request_1_2) + P-server_request_2_1) + P-server_request_2_2) + P-server_request_3_1) + P-server_request_3_2) + P-server_request_4_1) + P-server_request_4_2) + P-server_request_5_1) + P-server_request_5_2) + P-server_request_6_1) + P-server_request_6_2) + P-server_request_7_1) + P-server_request_7_2) + P-server_request_8_1) + P-server_request_8_2) + P-server_request_9_1) + P-server_request_9_2) + P-server_request_10_1) + P-server_request_10_2) + P-server_request_11_1) + P-server_request_11_2) + P-server_request_12_1) + P-server_request_12_2) + P-server_request_13_1) + P-server_request_13_2) + P-server_request_14_1) + P-server_request_14_2) + P-server_request_15_1) + P-server_request_15_2))) or EG (1 > ((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15)))
Query size reduced from 101 to 101 nodes (0.00 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.049412 seconds.

Query before reduction: (EG (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= (P-server_waiting_1 + P-server_waiting_2)) or (((not ((P-lb_idle_1 <= ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15)) and (((((((((((((((P-client_request_1 + P-client_request_2) + P-client_request_3) + P-client_request_4) + P-client_request_5) + P-client_request_6) + P-client_request_7) + P-client_request_8) + P-client_request_9) + P-client_request_10) + P-client_request_11) + P-client_request_12) + P-client_request_13) + P-client_request_14) + P-client_request_15) <= (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_load_2_12) + P-lb_load_2_13) + P-lb_load_2_14) + P-lb_load_2_15)))) and (not (not (1 <= ((((((((((((((P-client_idle_1 + P-client_idle_2) + P-client_idle_3) + P-client_idle_4) + P-client_idle_5) + P-client_idle_6) + P-client_idle_7) + P-client_idle_8) + P-client_idle_9) + P-client_idle_10) + P-client_idle_11) + P-client_idle_12) + P-client_idle_13) + P-client_idle_14) + P-client_idle_15))))) and AG (not (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= P-lb_balancing_1))))
Query after reduction: (EG (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) <= (P-server_waiting_1 + P-server_waiting_2)) or ((((P-lb_idle_1 > ((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15)) or (((((((((((((((P-client_request_1 + P-client_request_2) + P-client_request_3) + P-client_request_4) + P-client_request_5) + P-client_request_6) + P-client_request_7) + P-client_request_8) + P-client_request_9) + P-client_request_10) + P-client_request_11) + P-client_request_12) + P-client_request_13) + P-client_request_14) + P-client_request_15) > (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_load_2_12) + P-lb_load_2_13) + P-lb_load_2_14) + P-lb_load_2_15))) and (1 <= ((((((((((((((P-client_idle_1 + P-client_idle_2) + P-client_idle_3) + P-client_idle_4) + P-client_idle_5) + P-client_idle_6) + P-client_idle_7) + P-client_idle_8) + P-client_idle_9) + P-client_idle_10) + P-client_idle_11) + P-client_idle_12) + P-client_idle_13) + P-client_idle_14) + P-client_idle_15))) and AG (((((((((((((((P-client_ack_1 + P-client_ack_2) + P-client_ack_3) + P-client_ack_4) + P-client_ack_5) + P-client_ack_6) + P-client_ack_7) + P-client_ack_8) + P-client_ack_9) + P-client_ack_10) + P-client_ack_11) + P-client_ack_12) + P-client_ack_13) + P-client_ack_14) + P-client_ack_15) > P-lb_balancing_1)))
Query size reduced from 225 to 225 nodes (0.00 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.053111 seconds.

Query before reduction: A (AX (1 <= (P-server_idle_1 + P-server_idle_2)) U AG (1 <= ((((((((((((((P-client_request_1 + P-client_request_2) + P-client_request_3) + P-client_request_4) + P-client_request_5) + P-client_request_6) + P-client_request_7) + P-client_request_8) + P-client_request_9) + P-client_request_10) + P-client_request_11) + P-client_request_12) + P-client_request_13) + P-client_request_14) + P-client_request_15)))
Query after reduction: A (AX (1 <= (P-server_idle_1 + P-server_idle_2)) U AG (1 <= ((((((((((((((P-client_request_1 + P-client_request_2) + P-client_request_3) + P-client_request_4) + P-client_request_5) + P-client_request_6) + P-client_request_7) + P-client_request_8) + P-client_request_9) + P-client_request_10) + P-client_request_11) + P-client_request_12) + P-client_request_13) + P-client_request_14) + P-client_request_15)))
Query size reduced from 39 to 39 nodes (0.00 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.016529 seconds.

Query before reduction: E (((((P-server_idle_1 + P-server_idle_2) <= (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-lb_load_1_0 + P-lb_load_1_1) + P-lb_load_1_2) + P-lb_load_1_3) + P-lb_load_1_4) + P-lb_load_1_5) + P-lb_load_1_6) + P-lb_load_1_7) + P-lb_load_1_8) + P-lb_load_1_9) + P-lb_load_1_10) + P-lb_load_1_11) + P-lb_load_1_12) + P-lb_load_1_13) + P-lb_load_1_14) + P-lb_load_1_15) + P-lb_load_2_0) + P-lb_load_2_1) + P-lb_load_2_2) + P-lb_load_2_3) + P-lb_load_2_4) + P-lb_load_2_5) + P-lb_load_2_6) + P-lb_load_2_7) + P-lb_load_2_8) + P-lb_load_2_9) + P-lb_load_2_10) + P-lb_load_2_11) + P-lb_load_2_12) + P-lb_load_2_13) + P-lb_load_2_14) + P-lb_load_2_15)) or ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((P-server_request_1_1 + P-server_request_1_2) + P-server_request_2_1) + P-server_request_2_2) + P-server_request_3_1) + P-server_request_3_2) + P-server_request_4_1) + P-server_request_4_2) + P-server_request_5_1) + P-server_request_5_2) + P-server_request_6_1) + P-server_request_6_2) + P-server_request_7_1) + P-server_request_7_2) + P-server_request_8_1) + P-server_request_8_2) + P-server_request_9_1) + P-server_request_9_2) + P-server_request_10_1) + P-server_request_10_2) + P-server_request_11_1) + P-server_request_11_2) + P-server_request_12_1) + P-server_request_12_2) + P-server_request_13_1) + P-server_request_13_2) + P-server_request_14_1) + P-server_request_14_2) + P-server_request_15_1) + P-server_request_15_2) <= ((((((((((((((P-client_waiting_1 + P-client_waiting_2) + P-client_waiting_3) + P-client_waiting_4) + P-client_waiting_5) + P-client_waiting_6) + P-client_waiting_7) + P-client_waiting_8) + P-client_waiting_9) + P-client_waiting_10) + P-client_waiting_11) + P-client_waiting_12) + P-client_waiting_13) + P-client_waiting_14) + P-client_waiting_15))) and (((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15) <= (P-server_notification_1 + P-server_notification_2))) U EG (2 <= (P-server_idle_1 + P-server_idle_2)))
Query after reduction: E ((((((((((((((((P-lb_routing_1_1 + P-lb_routing_1_2) + P-lb_routing_1_3) + P-lb_routing_1_4) + P-lb_routing_1_5) + P-lb_routing_1_6) + P-lb_routing_1_7) + P-lb_routing_1_8) + P-lb_routing_1_9) + P-lb_routing_1_10) + P-lb_routing_1_11) + P-lb_routing_1_12) + P-lb_routing_1_13) + P-lb_routing_1_14) + P-lb_routing_1_15) <= (P-server_notification_1 + P-server_notification_2)) U EG (2 <= (P-server_idle_1 + P-server_idle_2)))
Query size reduced from 198 to 40 nodes (79.80 percent reduction).
Query reduction finished after 0.027355 seconds.
End of script.

BK_STOP 1494840915397

--------------------
content from stderr:

terminate called after throwing an instance of 'std::bad_alloc'
what(): std::bad_alloc
Command terminated by signal 6
Command being timed: "timeout 539 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 1"
User time (seconds): 140.59
System time (seconds): 6.39
Percent of CPU this job got: 99%
Elapsed (wall clock) time (h:mm:ss or m:ss): 2:27.00
Average shared text size (kbytes): 0
Average unshared data size (kbytes): 0
Average stack size (kbytes): 0
Average total size (kbytes): 0
Maximum resident set size (kbytes): 14438328
Average resident set size (kbytes): 0
Major (requiring I/O) page faults: 0
Minor (reclaiming a frame) page faults: 3739893
Voluntary context switches: 5
Involuntary context switches: 279
Swaps: 0
File system inputs: 384
File system outputs: 8
Socket messages sent: 0
Socket messages received: 0
Signals delivered: 0
Page size (bytes): 4096
Exit status: 0
terminate called after throwing an instance of 'std::bad_alloc'
what(): std::bad_alloc
Command terminated by signal 6
Command being timed: "timeout 617 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 4"
User time (seconds): 318.62
System time (seconds): 6.34
Percent of CPU this job got: 99%
Elapsed (wall clock) time (h:mm:ss or m:ss): 5:25.05
Average shared text size (kbytes): 0
Average unshared data size (kbytes): 0
Average stack size (kbytes): 0
Average total size (kbytes): 0
Maximum resident set size (kbytes): 14499220
Average resident set size (kbytes): 0
Major (requiring I/O) page faults: 0
Minor (reclaiming a frame) page faults: 3625062
Voluntary context switches: 3
Involuntary context switches: 1133
Swaps: 0
File system inputs: 0
File system outputs: 8
Socket messages sent: 0
Socket messages received: 0
Signals delivered: 0
Page size (bytes): 4096
Exit status: 0
Command terminated by signal 11
Command being timed: "timeout 689 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 8"
User time (seconds): 160.56
System time (seconds): 5.96
Percent of CPU this job got: 99%
Elapsed (wall clock) time (h:mm:ss or m:ss): 2:46.52
Average shared text size (kbytes): 0
Average unshared data size (kbytes): 0
Average stack size (kbytes): 0
Average total size (kbytes): 0
Maximum resident set size (kbytes): 14499468
Average resident set size (kbytes): 0
Major (requiring I/O) page faults: 0
Minor (reclaiming a frame) page faults: 3625181
Voluntary context switches: 3
Involuntary context switches: 295
Swaps: 0
File system inputs: 0
File system outputs: 0
Socket messages sent: 0
Socket messages received: 0
Signals delivered: 0
Page size (bytes): 4096
Exit status: 0
Command terminated by signal 11
Command being timed: "timeout 863 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 9"
User time (seconds): 160.40
System time (seconds): 6.16
Percent of CPU this job got: 99%
Elapsed (wall clock) time (h:mm:ss or m:ss): 2:46.66
Average shared text size (kbytes): 0
Average unshared data size (kbytes): 0
Average stack size (kbytes): 0
Average total size (kbytes): 0
Maximum resident set size (kbytes): 14499396
Average resident set size (kbytes): 0
Major (requiring I/O) page faults: 0
Minor (reclaiming a frame) page faults: 3625162
Voluntary context switches: 3
Involuntary context switches: 458
Swaps: 0
File system inputs: 0
File system outputs: 0
Socket messages sent: 0
Socket messages received: 0
Signals delivered: 0
Page size (bytes): 4096
Exit status: 0
Command terminated by signal 11
Command being timed: "timeout 1210 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 10"
User time (seconds): 138.34
System time (seconds): 6.18
Percent of CPU this job got: 99%
Elapsed (wall clock) time (h:mm:ss or m:ss): 2:24.53
Average shared text size (kbytes): 0
Average unshared data size (kbytes): 0
Average stack size (kbytes): 0
Average total size (kbytes): 0
Maximum resident set size (kbytes): 14494324
Average resident set size (kbytes): 0
Major (requiring I/O) page faults: 0
Minor (reclaiming a frame) page faults: 3753948
Voluntary context switches: 3
Involuntary context switches: 338
Swaps: 0
File system inputs: 0
File system outputs: 0
Socket messages sent: 0
Socket messages received: 0
Signals delivered: 0
Page size (bytes): 4096
Exit status: 0
Command terminated by signal 11
Command being timed: "timeout 2274 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 14"
User time (seconds): 149.76
System time (seconds): 6.03
Percent of CPU this job got: 99%
Elapsed (wall clock) time (h:mm:ss or m:ss): 2:35.80
Average shared text size (kbytes): 0
Average unshared data size (kbytes): 0
Average stack size (kbytes): 0
Average total size (kbytes): 0
Maximum resident set size (kbytes): 14499492
Average resident set size (kbytes): 0
Major (requiring I/O) page faults: 0
Minor (reclaiming a frame) page faults: 3625186
Voluntary context switches: 3
Involuntary context switches: 282
Swaps: 0
File system inputs: 0
File system outputs: 0
Socket messages sent: 0
Socket messages received: 0
Signals delivered: 0
Page size (bytes): 4096
Exit status: 0
terminate called after throwing an instance of 'std::bad_alloc'
what(): std::bad_alloc
Command terminated by signal 6
Command being timed: "timeout 2119 /home/mcc/BenchKit/bin/verifypn-linux64 -s DFS -d 100 -q 100 -p ./model.pnml ./CTLCardinality.xml -x 1,4,8,9,10,14"
User time (seconds): 138.04
System time (seconds): 6.33
Percent of CPU this job got: 99%
Elapsed (wall clock) time (h:mm:ss or m:ss): 2:24.45
Average shared text size (kbytes): 0
Average unshared data size (kbytes): 0
Average stack size (kbytes): 0
Average total size (kbytes): 0
Maximum resident set size (kbytes): 14438452
Average resident set size (kbytes): 0
Major (requiring I/O) page faults: 0
Minor (reclaiming a frame) page faults: 3739922
Voluntary context switches: 3
Involuntary context switches: 401
Swaps: 0
File system inputs: 0
File system outputs: 8
Socket messages sent: 0
Socket messages received: 0
Signals delivered: 0
Page size (bytes): 4096
Exit status: 0

Sequence of Actions to be Executed by the VM

This is useful if one wants to reexecute the tool in the VM from the submitted image disk.

set -x
# this is for BenchKit: configuration of major elements for the test
export BK_INPUT="SimpleLoadBal-PT-15"
export BK_EXAMINATION="CTLCardinality"
export BK_TOOL="tapaal"
export BK_RESULT_DIR="/tmp/BK_RESULTS/OUTPUTS"
export BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT="3600"
export BK_MEMORY_CONFINEMENT="16384"

# this is specific to your benchmark or test

export BIN_DIR="$HOME/BenchKit/bin"

# remove the execution directoty if it exists (to avoid increse of .vmdk images)
if [ -d execution ] ; then
rm -rf execution
fi

tar xzf /home/mcc/BenchKit/INPUTS/SimpleLoadBal-PT-15.tgz
mv SimpleLoadBal-PT-15 execution

# this is for BenchKit: explicit launching of the test

cd execution
echo "====================================================================="
echo " Generated by BenchKit 2-3254"
echo " Executing tool tapaal"
echo " Input is SimpleLoadBal-PT-15, examination is CTLCardinality"
echo " Time confinement is $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT seconds"
echo " Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes"
echo " Number of cores is 4"
echo " Run identifier is r069-csrt-149440964100381"
echo "====================================================================="
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stdout:"
echo
echo "=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)"
echo
if [ "CTLCardinality" = "UpperBounds" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of positive values"
echo NUM_VECTOR
elif [ "CTLCardinality" != "StateSpace" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of booleans"
echo BOOL_VECTOR
else
echo "no data necessary for post analysis"
fi
echo
if [ -f "CTLCardinality.txt" ] ; then
echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)"
for x in $(grep Property CTLCardinality.txt | cut -d ' ' -f 2 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
elif [ -f "CTLCardinality.xml" ] ; then # for cunf (txt files deleted;-)
echo echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from xml file)"
for x in $(grep '' CTLCardinality.xml | cut -d '>' -f 2 | cut -d '<' -f 1 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
fi
echo
echo "=== Now, execution of the tool begins"
echo
echo -n "BK_START "
date -u +%s%3N
echo
timeout -s 9 $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT bash -c "/home/mcc/BenchKit/BenchKit_head.sh 2> STDERR ; echo ; echo -n \"BK_STOP \" ; date -u +%s%3N"
if [ $? -eq 137 ] ; then
echo
echo "BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT_REACHED"
fi
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stderr:"
echo
cat STDERR ;