Execution Chart

We display below the execution chart for this examination (boot time has been removed).

Trace from the execution

Waiting for the VM to be ready (probing ssh)
...........
=====================================================================
Generated by BenchKit 2-2979
Executing tool tapaalPAR
Input is SimpleLoadBal-PT-15, examination is ReachabilityCardinality
Time confinement is 3600 seconds
Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes
Number of cores is 4
Run identifier is r124kn-qhx2-146373369400079
=====================================================================

--------------------
content from stdout:

=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)

The expected result is a vector of booleans
BOOL_VECTOR

here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-0
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-1
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-10
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-11
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-12
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-13
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-14
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-15
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-2
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-3
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-4
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-5
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-6
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-7
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-8
FORMULA_NAME SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-9

=== Now, execution of the tool begins

BK_START 1464383640369


*****************************************
TAPAAL onthefly-PAR performing ReachabilityCardinality search
*****************************************

verifypn -o mc -c 4 -n model.pnml ReachabilityCardinality.xml
SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-0: EF ( not((not((2 <= ("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2"))) or ((3 <= ("P-lb_routing_1_1" + "P-lb_routing_1_2" + "P-lb_routing_1_3" + "P-lb_routing_1_4" + "P-lb_routing_1_5" + "P-lb_routing_1_6" + "P-lb_routing_1_7" + "P-lb_routing_1_8" + "P-lb_routing_1_9" + "P-lb_routing_1_10" + "P-lb_routing_1_11" + "P-lb_routing_1_12" + "P-lb_routing_1_13" + "P-lb_routing_1_14" + "P-lb_routing_1_15")) and (2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15"))))) )

query: EF ( not((not((2 <= ("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2"))) or ((3 <= ("P-lb_routing_1_1" + "P-lb_routing_1_2" + "P-lb_routing_1_3" + "P-lb_routing_1_4" + "P-lb_routing_1_5" + "P-lb_routing_1_6" + "P-lb_routing_1_7" + "P-lb_routing_1_8" + "P-lb_routing_1_9" + "P-lb_routing_1_10" + "P-lb_routing_1_11" + "P-lb_routing_1_12" + "P-lb_routing_1_13" + "P-lb_routing_1_14" + "P-lb_routing_1_15")) and (2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15"))))) )
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-0 TRUE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

Query is satisfied.

SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-1: not EF not ( (not((1 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15"))) and (("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2") <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15"))) )

query: EF not ( (not((1 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15"))) and (("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2") <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15"))) )
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-1 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

Query is NOT satisfied.

SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-2: not EF not ( ((("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15") <= ("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15")) or (((3 <= ("P-client_request_1" + "P-client_request_2" + "P-client_request_3" + "P-client_request_4" + "P-client_request_5" + "P-client_request_6" + "P-client_request_7" + "P-client_request_8" + "P-client_request_9" + "P-client_request_10" + "P-client_request_11" + "P-client_request_12" + "P-client_request_13" + "P-client_request_14" + "P-client_request_15")) or (1 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15"))) and ((1 <= ("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2")) and (1 <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))))) )

query: EF not ( ((("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15") <= ("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15")) or (((3 <= ("P-client_request_1" + "P-client_request_2" + "P-client_request_3" + "P-client_request_4" + "P-client_request_5" + "P-client_request_6" + "P-client_request_7" + "P-client_request_8" + "P-client_request_9" + "P-client_request_10" + "P-client_request_11" + "P-client_request_12" + "P-client_request_13" + "P-client_request_14" + "P-client_request_15")) or (1 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15"))) and ((1 <= ("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2")) and (1 <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))))) )
SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-3: not EF not ( ((((2 <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or (("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15") <= "P-lb_balancing_1")) and ((1 <= ("P-lb_routing_1_1" + "P-lb_routing_1_2" + "P-lb_routing_1_3" + "P-lb_routing_1_4" + "P-lb_routing_1_5" + "P-lb_routing_1_6" + "P-lb_routing_1_7" + "P-lb_routing_1_8" + "P-lb_routing_1_9" + "P-lb_routing_1_10" + "P-lb_routing_1_11" + "P-lb_routing_1_12" + "P-lb_routing_1_13" + "P-lb_routing_1_14" + "P-lb_routing_1_15")) and (("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2") <= ("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2")))) or not(((2 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15")) and (("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15") <= "P-lb_balancing_1")))) )

query: EF not ( ((((2 <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or (("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15") <= "P-lb_balancing_1")) and ((1 <= ("P-lb_routing_1_1" + "P-lb_routing_1_2" + "P-lb_routing_1_3" + "P-lb_routing_1_4" + "P-lb_routing_1_5" + "P-lb_routing_1_6" + "P-lb_routing_1_7" + "P-lb_routing_1_8" + "P-lb_routing_1_9" + "P-lb_routing_1_10" + "P-lb_routing_1_11" + "P-lb_routing_1_12" + "P-lb_routing_1_13" + "P-lb_routing_1_14" + "P-lb_routing_1_15")) and (("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2") <= ("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2")))) or not(((2 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15")) and (("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15") <= "P-lb_balancing_1")))) )
SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-4: not EF not ( ((2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15")) or (((("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15") <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or (("P-server_waiting_1" + "P-server_waiting_2") <= ("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15"))) or not((("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2") <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15"))))) )

query: EF not ( ((2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15")) or (((("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15") <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or (("P-server_waiting_1" + "P-server_waiting_2") <= ("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15"))) or not((("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2") <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15"))))) )
SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-5: EF ( not((("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2") <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15"))) )

query: EF ( not((("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2") <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15"))) )
SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-6: not EF not ( (((1 <= ("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2")) or not((("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2") <= "P-lb_idle_1"))) or ((2 <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2")) and not((3 <= ("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15"))))) )

query: EF not ( (((1 <= ("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2")) or not((("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2") <= "P-lb_idle_1"))) or ((2 <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2")) and not((3 <= ("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15"))))) )
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-6 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

Query is NOT satisfied.

SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-7: EF ( (2 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15")) )

query: EF ( (2 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15")) )
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-7 TRUE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

Query is satisfied.

SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-8: EF ( (not(((1 <= ("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2")) or ("P-lb_balancing_1" <= ("P-server_waiting_1" + "P-server_waiting_2")))) and not((("P-server_waiting_1" + "P-server_waiting_2") <= "P-lb_idle_1"))) )

query: EF ( (not(((1 <= ("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2")) or ("P-lb_balancing_1" <= ("P-server_waiting_1" + "P-server_waiting_2")))) and not((("P-server_waiting_1" + "P-server_waiting_2") <= "P-lb_idle_1"))) )
SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-9: not EF not ( (not(((1 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15")) and (2 <= ("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2")))) and (not((2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15"))) or not((2 <= ("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2"))))) )

query: EF not ( (not(((1 <= ("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15")) and (2 <= ("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2")))) and (not((2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15"))) or not((2 <= ("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2"))))) )
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-9 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

Query is NOT satisfied.

SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-10: EF ( (((("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15") <= ("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2")) and not((2 <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")))) and not(not((1 <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))))) )

query: EF ( (((("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15") <= ("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2")) and not((2 <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")))) and not(not((1 <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))))) )
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-10 TRUE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

Query is satisfied.

SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-11: not EF not ( not((not(("P-lb_idle_1" <= ("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2"))) and (("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2") <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15")))) )

query: EF not ( not((not(("P-lb_idle_1" <= ("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2"))) and (("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2") <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15")))) )
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-11 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

Query is NOT satisfied.

SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-12: not EF not ( ((3 <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or ((("P-lb_routing_1_1" + "P-lb_routing_1_2" + "P-lb_routing_1_3" + "P-lb_routing_1_4" + "P-lb_routing_1_5" + "P-lb_routing_1_6" + "P-lb_routing_1_7" + "P-lb_routing_1_8" + "P-lb_routing_1_9" + "P-lb_routing_1_10" + "P-lb_routing_1_11" + "P-lb_routing_1_12" + "P-lb_routing_1_13" + "P-lb_routing_1_14" + "P-lb_routing_1_15") <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or not((("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15") <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))))) )

query: EF not ( ((3 <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or ((("P-lb_routing_1_1" + "P-lb_routing_1_2" + "P-lb_routing_1_3" + "P-lb_routing_1_4" + "P-lb_routing_1_5" + "P-lb_routing_1_6" + "P-lb_routing_1_7" + "P-lb_routing_1_8" + "P-lb_routing_1_9" + "P-lb_routing_1_10" + "P-lb_routing_1_11" + "P-lb_routing_1_12" + "P-lb_routing_1_13" + "P-lb_routing_1_14" + "P-lb_routing_1_15") <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or not((("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15") <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))))) )
SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-13: not EF not ( ((((("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15") <= ("P-client_request_1" + "P-client_request_2" + "P-client_request_3" + "P-client_request_4" + "P-client_request_5" + "P-client_request_6" + "P-client_request_7" + "P-client_request_8" + "P-client_request_9" + "P-client_request_10" + "P-client_request_11" + "P-client_request_12" + "P-client_request_13" + "P-client_request_14" + "P-client_request_15")) and (("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2") <= ("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2"))) or (("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2") <= "P-lb_balancing_1")) or (((("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2") <= ("P-client_request_1" + "P-client_request_2" + "P-client_request_3" + "P-client_request_4" + "P-client_request_5" + "P-client_request_6" + "P-client_request_7" + "P-client_request_8" + "P-client_request_9" + "P-client_request_10" + "P-client_request_11" + "P-client_request_12" + "P-client_request_13" + "P-client_request_14" + "P-client_request_15")) or (3 <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))) and not((2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15"))))) )

query: EF not ( ((((("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15") <= ("P-client_request_1" + "P-client_request_2" + "P-client_request_3" + "P-client_request_4" + "P-client_request_5" + "P-client_request_6" + "P-client_request_7" + "P-client_request_8" + "P-client_request_9" + "P-client_request_10" + "P-client_request_11" + "P-client_request_12" + "P-client_request_13" + "P-client_request_14" + "P-client_request_15")) and (("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2") <= ("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2"))) or (("P-server_processed_1" + "P-server_processed_2") <= "P-lb_balancing_1")) or (((("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2") <= ("P-client_request_1" + "P-client_request_2" + "P-client_request_3" + "P-client_request_4" + "P-client_request_5" + "P-client_request_6" + "P-client_request_7" + "P-client_request_8" + "P-client_request_9" + "P-client_request_10" + "P-client_request_11" + "P-client_request_12" + "P-client_request_13" + "P-client_request_14" + "P-client_request_15")) or (3 <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))) and not((2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15"))))) )
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-13 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

Query is NOT satisfied.

SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-14: not EF not ( ((((("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15") <= "P-lb_balancing_1") and (("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15") <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))) and (3 <= ("P-client_request_1" + "P-client_request_2" + "P-client_request_3" + "P-client_request_4" + "P-client_request_5" + "P-client_request_6" + "P-client_request_7" + "P-client_request_8" + "P-client_request_9" + "P-client_request_10" + "P-client_request_11" + "P-client_request_12" + "P-client_request_13" + "P-client_request_14" + "P-client_request_15"))) or not(not((("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2") <= ("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15"))))) )

query: EF not ( ((((("P-client_ack_1" + "P-client_ack_2" + "P-client_ack_3" + "P-client_ack_4" + "P-client_ack_5" + "P-client_ack_6" + "P-client_ack_7" + "P-client_ack_8" + "P-client_ack_9" + "P-client_ack_10" + "P-client_ack_11" + "P-client_ack_12" + "P-client_ack_13" + "P-client_ack_14" + "P-client_ack_15") <= "P-lb_balancing_1") and (("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15") <= ("P-server_notification_ack_1" + "P-server_notification_ack_2"))) and (3 <= ("P-client_request_1" + "P-client_request_2" + "P-client_request_3" + "P-client_request_4" + "P-client_request_5" + "P-client_request_6" + "P-client_request_7" + "P-client_request_8" + "P-client_request_9" + "P-client_request_10" + "P-client_request_11" + "P-client_request_12" + "P-client_request_13" + "P-client_request_14" + "P-client_request_15"))) or not(not((("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2") <= ("P-client_idle_1" + "P-client_idle_2" + "P-client_idle_3" + "P-client_idle_4" + "P-client_idle_5" + "P-client_idle_6" + "P-client_idle_7" + "P-client_idle_8" + "P-client_idle_9" + "P-client_idle_10" + "P-client_idle_11" + "P-client_idle_12" + "P-client_idle_13" + "P-client_idle_14" + "P-client_idle_15"))))) )
SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-15: not EF not ( ((1 <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or (((("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2") <= ("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2")) or (2 <= ("P-server_waiting_1" + "P-server_waiting_2"))) or not((("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15") <= ("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2"))))) )

query: EF not ( ((1 <= ("P-client_waiting_1" + "P-client_waiting_2" + "P-client_waiting_3" + "P-client_waiting_4" + "P-client_waiting_5" + "P-client_waiting_6" + "P-client_waiting_7" + "P-client_waiting_8" + "P-client_waiting_9" + "P-client_waiting_10" + "P-client_waiting_11" + "P-client_waiting_12" + "P-client_waiting_13" + "P-client_waiting_14" + "P-client_waiting_15")) or (((("P-server_request_1_1" + "P-server_request_1_2" + "P-server_request_2_1" + "P-server_request_2_2" + "P-server_request_3_1" + "P-server_request_3_2" + "P-server_request_4_1" + "P-server_request_4_2" + "P-server_request_5_1" + "P-server_request_5_2" + "P-server_request_6_1" + "P-server_request_6_2" + "P-server_request_7_1" + "P-server_request_7_2" + "P-server_request_8_1" + "P-server_request_8_2" + "P-server_request_9_1" + "P-server_request_9_2" + "P-server_request_10_1" + "P-server_request_10_2" + "P-server_request_11_1" + "P-server_request_11_2" + "P-server_request_12_1" + "P-server_request_12_2" + "P-server_request_13_1" + "P-server_request_13_2" + "P-server_request_14_1" + "P-server_request_14_2" + "P-server_request_15_1" + "P-server_request_15_2") <= ("P-server_idle_1" + "P-server_idle_2")) or (2 <= ("P-server_waiting_1" + "P-server_waiting_2"))) or not((("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15") <= ("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2"))))) )
SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-0: EF ( not((not((2 <= ("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2"))) or ((3 <= ("P-lb_routing_1_1" + "P-lb_routing_1_2" + "P-lb_routing_1_3" + "P-lb_routing_1_4" + "P-lb_routing_1_5" + "P-lb_routing_1_6" + "P-lb_routing_1_7" + "P-lb_routing_1_8" + "P-lb_routing_1_9" + "P-lb_routing_1_10" + "P-lb_routing_1_11" + "P-lb_routing_1_12" + "P-lb_routing_1_13" + "P-lb_routing_1_14" + "P-lb_routing_1_15")) and (2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15"))))) )

query: EF ( not((not((2 <= ("P-server_notification_1" + "P-server_notification_2"))) or ((3 <= ("P-lb_routing_1_1" + "P-lb_routing_1_2" + "P-lb_routing_1_3" + "P-lb_routing_1_4" + "P-lb_routing_1_5" + "P-lb_routing_1_6" + "P-lb_routing_1_7" + "P-lb_routing_1_8" + "P-lb_routing_1_9" + "P-lb_routing_1_10" + "P-lb_routing_1_11" + "P-lb_routing_1_12" + "P-lb_routing_1_13" + "P-lb_routing_1_14" + "P-lb_routing_1_15")) and (2 <= ("P-lb_load_1_0" + "P-lb_load_1_1" + "P-lb_load_1_2" + "P-lb_load_1_3" + "P-lb_load_1_4" + "P-lb_load_1_5" + "P-lb_load_1_6" + "P-lb_load_1_7" + "P-lb_load_1_8" + "P-lb_load_1_9" + "P-lb_load_1_10" + "P-lb_load_1_11" + "P-lb_load_1_12" + "P-lb_load_1_13" + "P-lb_load_1_14" + "P-lb_load_1_15" + "P-lb_load_2_0" + "P-lb_load_2_1" + "P-lb_load_2_2" + "P-lb_load_2_3" + "P-lb_load_2_4" + "P-lb_load_2_5" + "P-lb_load_2_6" + "P-lb_load_2_7" + "P-lb_load_2_8" + "P-lb_load_2_9" + "P-lb_load_2_10" + "P-lb_load_2_11" + "P-lb_load_2_12" + "P-lb_load_2_13" + "P-lb_load_2_14" + "P-lb_load_2_15"))))) )
FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-1 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-13 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-9 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-7 TRUE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-10 TRUE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-6 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-11 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-0 TRUE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION

FORMULA SimpleLoadBal-COL-15-ReachabilityCardinality-2 FALSE TECHNIQUES PARALLEL_PROCESSING EXPLICIT STRUCTURAL_REDUCTION


BK_STOP 1464384579635

--------------------
content from stderr:

Sequence of Actions to be Executed by the VM

This is useful if one wants to reexecute the tool in the VM from the submitted image disk.

set -x
# this is for BenchKit: configuration of major elements for the test
export BK_INPUT="SimpleLoadBal-PT-15"
export BK_EXAMINATION="ReachabilityCardinality"
export BK_TOOL="tapaalPAR"
export BK_RESULT_DIR="/home/fko/BK_RESULTS/OUTPUTS"
export BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT="3600"
export BK_MEMORY_CONFINEMENT="16384"

# this is specific to your benchmark or test

export BIN_DIR="$HOME/BenchKit/bin"

# remove the execution directoty if it exists (to avoid increse of .vmdk images)
if [ -d execution ] ; then
rm -rf execution
fi

tar xzf /home/mcc/BenchKit/INPUTS/SimpleLoadBal-PT-15.tgz
mv SimpleLoadBal-PT-15 execution

# this is for BenchKit: explicit launching of the test

cd execution
echo "====================================================================="
echo " Generated by BenchKit 2-2979"
echo " Executing tool tapaalPAR"
echo " Input is SimpleLoadBal-PT-15, examination is ReachabilityCardinality"
echo " Time confinement is $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT seconds"
echo " Memory confinement is 16384 MBytes"
echo " Number of cores is 4"
echo " Run identifier is r124kn-qhx2-146373369400079"
echo "====================================================================="
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stdout:"
echo
echo "=== Data for post analysis generated by BenchKit (invocation template)"
echo
if [ "ReachabilityCardinality" = "UpperBounds" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of positive values"
echo NUM_VECTOR
elif [ "ReachabilityCardinality" != "StateSpace" ] ; then
echo "The expected result is a vector of booleans"
echo BOOL_VECTOR
else
echo "no data necessary for post analysis"
fi
echo
if [ -f "ReachabilityCardinality.txt" ] ; then
echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from text file)"
for x in $(grep Property ReachabilityCardinality.txt | cut -d ' ' -f 2 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
elif [ -f "ReachabilityCardinality.xml" ] ; then # for cunf (txt files deleted;-)
echo echo "here is the order used to build the result vector(from xml file)"
for x in $(grep '' ReachabilityCardinality.xml | cut -d '>' -f 2 | cut -d '<' -f 1 | sort -u) ; do
echo "FORMULA_NAME $x"
done
fi
echo
echo "=== Now, execution of the tool begins"
echo
echo -n "BK_START "
date -u +%s%3N
echo
timeout -s 9 $BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT bash -c "/home/mcc/BenchKit/BenchKit_head.sh 2> STDERR ; echo ; echo -n \"BK_STOP \" ; date -u +%s%3N"
if [ $? -eq 137 ] ; then
echo
echo "BK_TIME_CONFINEMENT_REACHED"
fi
echo
echo "--------------------"
echo "content from stderr:"
echo
cat STDERR ;