fond
Model Checking Contest 2022
12th edition, Bergen, Norway, June 21, 2022
Tapaal compared to other tools («Surprise» models, ReachabilityFireability)
Last Updated
Jun 22, 2022

Introduction

This page presents how Tapaal do cope efficiently with the ReachabilityFireability examination face to the other participating tools. In this page, we consider «Surprise» models.

The next sections will show chart comparing performances in terms of both memory and execution time.The x-axis corresponds to the challenging tool where the y-axes represents Tapaal' performances. Thus, points below the diagonal of a chart denote comparisons favorables to the tool while others corresponds to situations where the challenging tool performs better.

You might also find plots out of the range that denote the case were at least one tool could not answer appropriately (error, time-out, could not compute or did not competed).

Tapaal versus GreatSPN

Some statistics are displayed below, based on 412 runs (206 for Tapaal and 206 for GreatSPN, so there are 206 plots on each of the two charts). Each execution was allowed 1 hour and 16 GByte of memory. Then performance charts comparing Tapaal to GreatSPN are shown (you may click on one graph to enlarge it).

Statistics on the executions
  Tapaal GreatSPN Both tools   Tapaal GreatSPN
All computed OK 112 0 72   Smallest Memory Footprint
Tapaal = GreatSPN 1 Times tool wins 202 2
Tapaal > GreatSPN 16   Shortest Execution Time
Tapaal < GreatSPN 3 Times tool wins 163 41
Do not compete 0 0 0
Error detected 0 0 0  
Cannot Compute + Time-out 0 112 2


On the chart below, denote cases where the two tools did computed all results without error, denote cases where the two tool did computed the same number of values (but not al values in the examination), denote cases where Tapaal computed more values than GreatSPN, denote cases where Tapaal computed less values than GreatSPN, denote the cases where at least one tool did not competed, denote the cases where at least one tool computed a bad value and denote the cases where at least one tool stated it could not compute a result or timed-out.

Tapaal wins when points are below the diagonal, GreatSPN wins when points are above the diagonal.

memory chart time chart

Tapaal versus ITS-Tools

Some statistics are displayed below, based on 412 runs (206 for Tapaal and 206 for ITS-Tools, so there are 206 plots on each of the two charts). Each execution was allowed 1 hour and 16 GByte of memory. Then performance charts comparing Tapaal to ITS-Tools are shown (you may click on one graph to enlarge it).

Statistics on the executions
  Tapaal ITS-Tools Both tools   Tapaal ITS-Tools
All computed OK 0 2 136   Smallest Memory Footprint
Tapaal = ITS-Tools 11 Times tool wins 154 52
Tapaal > ITS-Tools 16   Shortest Execution Time
Tapaal < ITS-Tools 41 Times tool wins 107 99
Do not compete 0 0 0
Error detected 0 0 0  
Cannot Compute + Time-out 2 0 0


On the chart below, denote cases where the two tools did computed all results without error, denote cases where the two tool did computed the same number of values (but not al values in the examination), denote cases where Tapaal computed more values than ITS-Tools, denote cases where Tapaal computed less values than ITS-Tools, denote the cases where at least one tool did not competed, denote the cases where at least one tool computed a bad value and denote the cases where at least one tool stated it could not compute a result or timed-out.

Tapaal wins when points are below the diagonal, ITS-Tools wins when points are above the diagonal.

memory chart time chart

Tapaal versus smpt

Some statistics are displayed below, based on 412 runs (206 for Tapaal and 206 for smpt, so there are 206 plots on each of the two charts). Each execution was allowed 1 hour and 16 GByte of memory. Then performance charts comparing Tapaal to smpt are shown (you may click on one graph to enlarge it).

Statistics on the executions
  Tapaal smpt Both tools   Tapaal smpt
All computed OK 11 0 68   Smallest Memory Footprint
Tapaal = smpt 10 Times tool wins 175 29
Tapaal > smpt 96   Shortest Execution Time
Tapaal < smpt 19 Times tool wins 163 41
Do not compete 0 0 0
Error detected 0 0 0  
Cannot Compute + Time-out 0 11 2


On the chart below, denote cases where the two tools did computed all results without error, denote cases where the two tool did computed the same number of values (but not al values in the examination), denote cases where Tapaal computed more values than smpt, denote cases where Tapaal computed less values than smpt, denote the cases where at least one tool did not competed, denote the cases where at least one tool computed a bad value and denote the cases where at least one tool stated it could not compute a result or timed-out.

Tapaal wins when points are below the diagonal, smpt wins when points are above the diagonal.

memory chart time chart

Tapaal versus 2021-gold

Some statistics are displayed below, based on 412 runs (206 for Tapaal and 206 for 2021-gold, so there are 206 plots on each of the two charts). Each execution was allowed 1 hour and 16 GByte of memory. Then performance charts comparing Tapaal to 2021-gold are shown (you may click on one graph to enlarge it).

Statistics on the executions
  Tapaal 2021-gold Both tools   Tapaal 2021-gold
All computed OK 0 2 137   Smallest Memory Footprint
Tapaal = 2021-gold 16 Times tool wins 162 44
Tapaal > 2021-gold 13   Shortest Execution Time
Tapaal < 2021-gold 38 Times tool wins 113 93
Do not compete 0 0 0
Error detected 0 0 0  
Cannot Compute + Time-out 2 0 0


On the chart below, denote cases where the two tools did computed all results without error, denote cases where the two tool did computed the same number of values (but not al values in the examination), denote cases where Tapaal computed more values than 2021-gold, denote cases where Tapaal computed less values than 2021-gold, denote the cases where at least one tool did not competed, denote the cases where at least one tool computed a bad value and denote the cases where at least one tool stated it could not compute a result or timed-out.

Tapaal wins when points are below the diagonal, 2021-gold wins when points are above the diagonal.

memory chart time chart